Earlier this week, Jews all over the world celebrated Rosh Hashanah, the “head” of the Hebrew year. Just like many people do every January 1, Jewish people make “resolutions” each Rosh Hashanah. I happen to be no different. What’s my “resolution”? Basically to remind the rest of the world that I’m not dead yet and still have thoughts to share and principles to stand up for while I’m still alive and mentally functional.
One can think about lots of things during time away from blogging, but it’s no longer conceivable to write monstrous columns to cover all the bases and make up for lost time. So, for the sake of focus, efficiency and self-preservation, I’m going to write about one specific issue, state my thoughts and be done with it until the world hears from me again.
Well, this column’s issue addresses the intersection between stupidity and hypocrisy, one of my favorite issues to write about. Oh sure, stupidity and hypocrisy exist in so many ways, but our chat focuses on the special way foot-in-mouth disease brings out stupidity and hypocrisy in their purest forms, and what better examples of pure stupidity and hypocrisy are there than Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney and Tampa Bay Buccaneers head coach Greg Schiano. Talk about hitting the Daily Double!
In case you’ve lost track of current events while agonizing over MLB divisional and wild-card races, or the eventual outcome of BountyGate, or replacement officials in the NFL, or when Tim Tebow will part the Hudson River, Governor Romney, back in May, schmoozed with aristocrats in Boca Raton, Florida at a $50,000/plate dinner. Governor Romney, unaware a hidden video camera was near his podium, decided it made sense to schmooze “off the cuff” and... Wait! You’re gonna love it!... Told a roomful of rich white Floridians that he had no use for 47 percent of the voting public, because those folks didn’t pay any federal income taxes and were irreversibly and unconditionally aligned to and voting for President Barack Obama. I know... Ain’t it a hoot?! But wait... It gets better!
Governor Romney characterized that 47 percent as “believing that they are victims... dependent upon government... Believing government has a responsibility to care for them... Believing that they are entitled to health care, to food, to housing, to you-name-it... Entitlement... Blah, blah, blah... Government should give it to them.” And as if the violins needed queuing, Governor Romney lamented: “I’ll never convince them that they should take personal responsibility and care for their lives.” But alas, he has a change of heart during an appearance on Univision and proclaims he’s running a presidential campaign on behalf of 100 percent of Americans, whatever the hell that means at any random moment in his campaign.
Geez... If only the Hallmark Channel could produce movies so touching...
If you’ve seriously followed this train wreck of a presidential campaign since the GOP debates and primaries, you already know the former governor of Massachusetts is the epitome of contradiction, hypocrisy, and flaming rhetoric. Governor Romney is against the Affordable Health Care Act (affectionately referred to as “Obamacare”), but he created the same program for all the citizens of his state long before President Obama even ran for the Illinois state senate, and the governor apparently enjoys being known as the “Grandfather of Obamacare” when it suits his convenience.
Governor Romney believes in self-deportation of illegal immigrants, but would “like to staple a green card to every Ph.D. in the world and say ‘Come to America, we want you here.’” The governor also enjoys boasting about his Mexican-born grandfather every chance he gets, yet he’s less effusive regarding his several foreign bank accounts.
Governor Romney was dead-set against the auto industry bailout, but he loves to remind people that he owns a few General Motors vehicles and his wife drives “a couple of Cadillacs, actually.”
Governor Romney sees no use for the Environmental Protection Agency, but he likes it when “all the trees are the right height” in his home state of Michigan. Governor Romney, by the way, calls Michigan his home state, but he was governor of Massachusetts and owns homes in Florida, Utah and California.
Governor Romney “likes firing people”, but aside from his one term as governor of Massachusetts (2003-2007), he’s been perpetually unemployed longer than any individual I know. I’m curious to know what he writes for “Occupation/Profession” on his federal income tax returns... Aspiring Oligarch?! International Financier?! You figure he has to claim a creative title to reflect a personal tax rate of 13-14 percent on an annual income approaching $15 million, right?
Governor Romney accused all of his GOP primary challengers of running smear campaigns against him while his own super pac loyalists firebombed all challengers with scathing TV ads... To think folks called Arnold Swarzenegger “Governator”! And Mr. Romney will bet you 10 grand his hands were completely clean on these dirty political stunts!
Most inflaming and hypocritical of all, Governor Romney tells President Obama to take his “campaign of hate, divisiveness and class warfare back to Chicago” while spewing his own brand of hate, divisiveness and class warfare. Hate? What hate? the disingenuous governor wonders. Mr. Romney trails in most polls these days to a president categorized as “non-American, fraud, apologist, terrorist sympathizer, socialist, redistributionist...” and it likely eats at Mr. Romney, his supporters and fellow Republicans that he’s trailing a human being they deem unworthy to be more than a shoe-shiner. When a wealthy white political candidate publicly proclaims that our nation’s first multi-racial president “go back to where he came from”, only a complete idiot wouldn’t recognize that Chicago was not the first place on Mr. Romney’s mind, just like it isn’t on Sarah Palin’s mind, Donald Trump’s mind, or Kentucky Senator Mitch McConnell’s mind.
President Obama doesn’t get a complete pass on things either. Despite inheriting a complete mess from the Bush-43 administration in January 2009 and working against congressional Republicans hell-bent on sending our nation down the toilet for the sake of partisanship, he hasn’t thrown enough counterpunches when opponents attacked, nor has he pushed hard enough on key reforms in order to placate opposition. Yes, it rubs me wrong that he attends $40,000/plate fundraisers in Manhattan for his re-election campaign (I guess it costs $10,000 more to entertain wealthy bigots in Boca Raton?). Yes, he could’ve done much more during his first term, but he’s done far from nothing, the modus operandi of congressional Republicans. All things considered, at least he’s tried his damnedest to be everyone’s president and keep us from completely circling the drain, and at least gets my vote for a second term to continue our painful recovery.
Somehow this election is supposed to be about our nation’s struggling economy. Mr. Romney, in a September 19 Op-Ed to USA TODAY, promises to “deliver recovery, not dependency” and “policies [that] foster mobility.” In fact, from the very first words of Mr. Romney’s Op-Ed, he states: “Since our founding, America has promoted personal responsibility, the dignity of work and the value of education. These values made our nation the hope of the earth and out economy the envy of the world. Efforts that promote hard work and personal responsibility over government dependency make America strong. When the economy is growing and Americans are working, everyone involved has a shared sense of achievement, not to mention the basic sense of pride that comes with the paycheck they earn.”
Have I missed something within this preamble to another specifics-lacking self-pontification by Mr. Romney, but are these not the words of a man who himself has not earned a single paycheck since January 2007? What hard work has this individual been engaged in these past 69 months besides spending his personal fortune trying to convince American voters he deserves to be elected leader of the free world? C’mon, who’s kidding who here? I haven’t worked full-time in any academic position since my spinal injury in November 2006; applying Mr. Romney’s logic, I’m qualified to be Penn State’s next president.
Now, don’t get me wrong... Even as a staunch Democrat, I do see merit in many of Mr. Romney’s points. I do agree that our nation’s economic recovery has been too slow, that we need a LOT of new jobs, and good-paying jobs, in order to stimulate the economy, that the goal of every individual citizen should be personal responsibility and accomplishment, and that the fruits of your own labor taste a lot sweeter than if handed to you on the basis of bureaucratic technicality. And, yes, I do agree that lazy people indeed exist within our society, but my definition of “lazy” may be significantly different from “lazy” defined by angry white America.
I don’t, however, agree that the private sector is any more important or special than the public sector (and vice-versa). I don’t see why our economy can’t grow and thrive with job expansion by both sectors. I don’t agree that our nation is the hope of the world, nor do I agree that our economy is the envy of the world, because that arrogantly presumes every other country in the world is shit (pardon my language), and I do think that reflects well on a great country... Not the greatest country, but a great country. Most importantly, a paycheck may bring a sense of pride and accomplishment, but it’s not the ultimate measure of achievement or work. A paycheck in itself represents currency and purchasing power, and right now there are too many Americans “earning” paychecks of minimal currency and little purchasing power. How much pride people feel when the worth of their paycheck represents a choice between food on the table or gas in the car or any number of basic necessities is something I seriously doubt Mr. Romney comprehends or empathizes with, and that raises some serious philosophical questions about “work” and “paycheck.”
For example, I don’t earn one penny for writing this blog column, nor have I ever sought payment for my columns, but any of my columns represent work to me as I engage my mind and hands. In fact, it’s hard work and physically painful and exhausting, even with the benefit of a morphine pump surgically implanted inside my abdomen. When I can complete a column and see that it’s cohesive and coherent, I take pride and consider it one more accomplishment, albeit small, in my life. Yes, as meaningless as my columns may seem to the world, each new column is a small victory for me, keeping me alive and engaged one more day.
Do my columns stimulate the economy? Heck, I’m not even sure they stimulate my readership; it’s not like feedback comes back to me with regularity. But I hope a column stimulates thinking by a few folks and perhaps encourages folks to check out my books and buy them. It’s not a lot, but the royalties do constitute income, income I ultimately reinvest into my life and self-sustenance, my ongoing work and advocacy efforts, my health care, and our economy... Oh! And that income ultimately counts towards my federal income tax return.
Returning to Mr. Romney’s rhetoric about lazy people — i.e., moochers — the 47 percent who don’t pay federal income taxes and represent some undesirable segment of the American electorate, or at least Mitt Romney’s version of the American electorate still having a legal right to vote. We know exactly whom Mr. Romney thinks he’s referring to when he serves sociocultural red meat to the hoi-polloi of Boca Raton. He thinks he’s using slick code language to refer to the stereotypical low-income, racial minorities of the Welfare State, or any Norman Lear sitcom from the 1970s... Too unskilled to employ, too lazy to motivate or elevate, and too eager to accept public housing, food stamps, Medicaid and any other “freebies” the government is handing out. And that’s the key component in Mitt Romney’s vision of a broken America... The hand-out, the one-way flow of taxpayer dollars from bureaucracy to society’s dregs, slackers, and losers. Is it no wonder pundits like David Brooks and Chris Matthews view Mr. Romney as a real-life version of Thurston B. Howell from “Gilligan’s Island”? As I’ve opined many times before, is it no wonder peasants marched upon King Louis XVI’s castle with torches and pitchforks during the French Revolution?
Sorry to burst the arrogant bubble of people at the top of our nation’s pyramid, but their DNA is no better than anyone else’s, including yours and mine. Whether I’m disabled or able-bodied, employed in academia or making my efforts from home, I still consider myself an equal member of the human race and American society, no matter how many rich nitwits think they could buy and sell me a thousand times over. President Obama and First-Lady Michelle Obama both reminded us last month from the Democratic National Convention in Charlotte, North Carolina, that the size of our paychecks is meaningless compared to the jobs we do to earn those paychecks. Anybody can make lots of money, but not everybody can make a positive contribution to society. People like Mitt Romney’s crowd in Boca Raton, however, equate money with human value, not because money helps the world, but because money enhances their private corner of the world. Does this sound like the worldview of a person aspiring to be president for 100 percent of Americans?
What’s so amazing about Mr. Romney’s offensive verbalizations is that his wife of 42 years deals with Multiple Sclerosis, and Mr. Romney gives a considerable amount of charity through the Mormon church. How do such personal experiences and practices correspond to such empathy tone-deafness? Some folks argue that Mr. Romney is a “compassionate conservative” trapped in a presidential candidate campaigning as a “severe conservative.” While there may be merit to that assessment, I suspect Mr. Romney is no different than many 21st century Americans in the sense that Mr. Romney’s empathy is limited to his localized universe. In other words, he has at least sixty years of experience interacting with and recognizing a very small and privileged segment of our global population, so why should he suddenly care beyond that segment simply on the basis of their existence? It’s not like they existed before in his personal universe, did they?
And that’s sort of a common shortcoming we all have as Americans or global citizens. We’re so conditioned to concepts of “charity begins at home”, “take care of your own”, and “strength within the community” that we often forget there will always, unfortunately, be human beings without homes, or without anyone taking care of them, or who aren’t part of a community. We forget that human suffering is sometimes entrenched or long-term, and whatever our assistance efforts, they’re too short-term or cosmetic relative to very complex needs. We forget that suffering, sadly, always exists all over the world.
And yet we text donations to the Red Cross after a natural disaster, thinking our contribution in response to a hurricane covers our “humanity credit” for any earthquakes or tsunamis. It’s neither easy nor fair. We can’t realistically text the ideal level of donation every time natural disasters occur, because disasters usually outpace our monetary generosity, unless we simply think nickel and dime pledging makes a genuine impact. We wonder if it’s acceptable to reach a statute of limitations or threshold on sympathy. It’s human nature to get impatient with all the “bad stuff” in our world, right? Perhaps, but it’s not necessarily the most positive reflection on us, is it? Then again, most of us are not highly public celebrities or aspiring national leaders, so we get more leeway than very wealthy and public people like Mr. Romney.
I can give Mr. Romney a limited benefit of the doubt, given his wife’s battle with MS. Perhaps it’s an unfair imposition to expect him to care about every MS patient in the world, or every person dealing with a neurological condition. After all, he’s living with an MS patient every day, and we can assume he’s doing his part on behalf of his wife. The same can be said regarding anything else he already donates charity towards. He donates to his own house of worship in order to help others suffering a spectrum of medical ills. We don’t specifically know how many individual “causes” Mr. Romney’s charitable donations serve; we only know how much money is donated according to his federal income tax returns.
In a way, aren’t we all caring about the world in similar ways? Do we donate for every cause, or do we pick and choose where we can make the most impact? Do we donate to all houses of worship or just our own? Limiting our contributions doesn’t make us selfish hypocrites, but ignoring, discounting or denigrating the suffering of others barely beyond the tip of one’s nose does. There’s a fundamental difference between saying “gee, I wish I was able to help more” and “I really don’t worry or care about them.” It’s unrealistic to expect any President of the United States to be able to help everybody in need, but it’s not unrealistic to expect a President of the United States to want to help everybody in need.
Mr. Romney brands President Obama as “The Food Stamp President.” Have the number of Americans seeking and qualifying for public assistance increased since the 2008 election? Yes, it has. Do racial minorities constitute the majority of Americans qualifying for public assistance? No, they don’t, despite Mr. Romney’s desire to use racial minorities as poster children for public assistance and a convenient wedge issue to alarm wealthy white Americans. Are Food Stamps even the largest federal expenditure among “entitlement” programs? No, not by a long shot. According to the United States Office of Management and Budget, in 2011, Food Stamps and other nutrition program benefits accounted for $96 billion, the sixth-largest expenditure, behind Social Security ($725B), Medicare ($480B), Medicaid ($275B), Federal employee retirement ($124B), and unemployment insurance ($117B), and just ahead of veterans benefits ($71B).
What do these expenditures mean? Poverty and starvation demand approximately seven times less of our federal resources compared to simply being a senior citizen and retired. In fact, the annual budget expenditure for people age 65 and older (i.e., Social Security and Medicare, combined) represents more than three times the annual budget expenditure for poverty (i.e., Food Stamps and Medicaid, combined). Unless I’m mistaken, senior citizens represent one of Mr. Romney’s better supporting voter groups. Ironically, this voter group represents nearly one-fifth of the Americans Mr. Romney considers moochers. Is this an example of biting the hand that feeds you? It certainly seems an odd way of appreciating a vital voting constituency.
Who makes up the remainder of Mr. Romney’s moochers? Poor people, whether they’re employed or not; poverty is a bureaucratic classification based on annual income and size of your household. What many people overlook is that college students employed for the purpose of funding their education can fall into this category as well as members of our nation’s armed forces serving abroad to protect our rights and freedom. So, not only is Mr. Romney spitting on elderly voters, he’s spreading — no, make that redistributing -- the spit towards young voters who are new election process participants and the majority of absentee voters rising life for the rest of us. Golly, that’s gratitude for us, isn’t it?
Unless I’m mistaken, yet again, most Americans are eligible for Social Security and Medicare on the basis of years of employment, earning a paycheck, and paying into this safety net system through payroll withholdings. I’m under 65, yet receive Social Security and Medicare benefits on the basis of being permanently disabled and having paid into the system for 32 years of employment. Does this make me a moocher? My being non-employed is not voluntary. I’d certainly rather be back at a university full-time, doing what I did for 25 years prior to my spinal injury: teaching, helping young adults mature intellectually, and contributing to the growth of my academic community.
According to my 2011 federal income tax returns, I had an Adjusted Gross Income of $12,248 and paid $1,449 in federal income taxes, an effective tax rate of almost 12 percent, quite comparable to Mr. Romney’s. So, am I among the mooching 47 percent or the acceptable 53 percent? It’s not so clear-cut to me... I’m no longer employed on the basis of disability, I receive Social Security and Medicare benefits, I also receive $30/month in Food Stamps as well as other forms of public assistance towards utility bills, AND I pay federal income taxes, yet I’m likely a moocher in Mr. Romney’s view because I depend on the government to provide me money to house myself, feed myself, bathe and clothe myself, transport myself to medical providers, and keep myself alive. Do I expect these governmental benefits? Yes, I do. After 32 years of hard work and service, I should be able to live safely and comfortably — not regally — without having to wonder if my basic needs are being met on a monthly basis. The sobering reality is that my basic needs are not being met, because what I receive from the government isn’t enough to cover all my basic needs. Basic needs are not luxuries, and if politicians are telling us Social Security and Medicare recipients are living in luxury, they clearly haven’t visited me. There’s no perpetual money tree in my back yard, nor am I in possession of a winning lottery ticket yet to be cashed. I live check to check, just like a growing number of Americans exhausting funds to maintain the basics, wondering if groceries or medications will be a luxury. This is a reality Mr. Romney and his supporters cannot comprehend, because they’ve never lived life without a safety net or foundation. Mr. Romney has managed to enjoy and maintain a very lavish lifestyle in spite of being unemployed since January 2007. If he and his supporters can live this way, they’re unable to understand or tolerate people who can’t. They’re offended by the mere existence of people who can’t and propose socioeconomic engineering designed to elicit apology from people who have been repeatedly decimated by the Great Recession and other circumstances.
Ask yourselves: is Mitt Romney’s America ever going to help the decimated people reach a full recovery? No, it won’t, because everyone will need support just to regain an economic floor to build from, and Mr. Romney fails to understand why so many people lack that floor to begin with.
If Mr. Romney expecting some sort of apology from me, he’ll have a long wait. I can’t apologize for circumstances I never created, nor can I apologize for being in difficult circumstances. That’s as ridiculous an expectation as demanding apology from a child for contracting a cold, or an elderly person for aging. We’re not machines that never get sick or injured. We don’t live life in bubble wrap. But we clearly have a man running for President after years of living in his own bubble. With absolutely no apologies to Mr. Romney and his constituency of wealthy bigots, our nation was founded on the inalienable right to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, and those inalienable rights belong to everyone, not just those supporting the political aspirations of Mitt Romney or his socioeconomic class.
The sad irony is that my vote was still open and available to Mr. Romney a few months ago, before he decided to alienate every last person not of his ilk. Yes, I entertained the thought of voting for Mr. Romney, but not anymore. Am I better off than I was four years ago? It depends on the criteria contextualizing that question, but in the grand scheme of how my life has evolved since 2008, I’d have to say life overall in 2012 is significantly better. That hardly means I’m satisfied, and I was open to what Mr. Romney had to say and offer, which ultimately has been squat with a side order of insult.
In a democratic society, it’s really not my place to advise or influence anyone else’s vote. Everyone should vote honestly and according to their own view and values. Speaking only for myself, and as an example of what Mitt Romney considers wrong with America, I cannot, in good conscience, vote for him... Not because he’s wealthy. Not because his primary agenda involves preserving wealth among the wealthy. Not even because he considers people like me an example of what’s wrong for America’s economic future. I cannot vote for him because he sees no value or place for me in his vision of America’s economic future, and as someone living life from a wheelchair who believes life from a wheelchair can still have meaning, value and contributable worth, this is a deal-breaker when it comes to electing our nation’s president. One cannot see forward or see possibilities when your head is hidden so far up your ass.
Well, Governor Pot, meet Coach Kettle...
Speaking of hypocrisy, heads up asses and the inability to see forward, I introduce you all to Tampa Bay Buccaneers head coach Greg Schiano, formerly the head football coach at Rutgers University. Coach Schiano’s a classic “Jersey guy”... In fact, for those who are not big sports fans, the best way to describe Coach Schiano is to imagine what Governor Chris Christie would be like after Weight Watchers.
In case you didn’t know, Coach Schiano had a rather heated difference of opinion with New York Giants head coach Tom Coughlin after the conclusion of this past Sunday’s game at MetLife Stadium. To summarize the salient points, Schiano’s Bucs blew a 27-13 lead and lost 41-34, courtesy of Giants quarterback Eli Manning’s 510 yards passing and three touchdown passes. On the final play of the game, with five seconds left, Manning took the snap from center to complete a kneel down play and run out the clock. Either hoping for some incredible miracle or acting out frustration, Schiano ordered his defensive linemen to fire out towards the Giants offensive linemen and try to create a fumble during the snap exchange. No fumble resulted, but a few Giants linemen fell backwards into Manning and knocked him on his back while he was already on one knee. Since the “extra contact” with the quarterback came from guys on his own team, hitting Manning wasn’t illegal, event though it wasn’t exactly kosher. In other words, an “unwritten rule” was violated, sort of the equivalent to assassinating someone after a cease-fire order.
As a former football player, not to mention former Buccaneer, I’m not going to debate the pros and cons of unwritten rules, because I do see merit to both sides of the argument regarding the play in question. However, I am going to state my opinion regarding the aftermath that ensued between Schiano and Coughlin. In short, Schiano acted like an ass towards Coughlin during post-game interactions as well as towards the media during his press conference, and whatever positive message Schiano intended regarding a change in how the Buccaneers play competitive football, he completely negated it with total disregard for player safety.
Ah... Player safety, that ominous term hovering over the NFL like a litigation albatross. Yes, while the NFL braces itself for the class action suit of all time regarding post-career neurological damage, here comes Coach Schiano and his “tough play and hard hits are part of the game” mantra. Better yet, he snidely reminds everyone that blowing into knell-down formations was a regular practice at Rutgers, and it actually resulted in successful fumble recoveries on a few occasions. Having played football against Rutgers over thirty years ago, I can honestly say that no one’ impressed with these fumble recoveries or the prowess of Rutgers football players to cause such fumbles. In other words, who cares?! It’s Rutgers! Lest I remind everyone that Coach Schiano’s predecessor in Tampa Bay was a wonderful, well-intentioned young man named Raheem Morris, the former head coach at Hofstra University (FYI: Hofstra no longer has a football program due to budgetary issues). Coach Morris had lots of spunk and tough play ideals too... And he lasted two seasons before ownership gave him a pink slip. Key point to the lesson: stuff that works at the college level doesn’t necessarily fly at the professional level, including borderline cheap shots during kneel-down plays. If you’re gonna pull that stuff on other teams, other teams will eventually return the favor and bust up your quarterback, and that’s how the NFL is often referred to as “Not for Long” when it comes to coaching careers.
Fortunately, for everyone involved, the Giants didn’t fumble or recreate the infamous 1978 “Miracle in the Meadowlands” and no player on either team suffered a significant injury. But what happens if someone did? Think for a moment what would happen if a submarining Buccaneer defensive player hit a Giant offensive lineman with enough force to go backwards into Eli Manning’s leg and break it, or tear up a knee? In a split second, the Giants season is completely changed and Manning’s career potentially ruined. Not only does this hurt the Giants on the field, it also hurts at the box office as a team without its marquee player plays the rest of the season in a half-empty stadium and on television to a fraction of loyal fans. Fewer fans at the stadium kills revenue. Fewer fans watching on TV kills ratings and network revenue. A really bad season potentially kills local business revenue in terms of selling team jerseys and other clothing items not to mention local restaurants. In fact, the only positive outcome in the event of Eli Manning suffering a season-ending injury is less traffic congestion in East Rutherford.
Look, injuries happen and are unfortunately part of the game; who better than me to tell you this. Well, guess what? Who better than Coach Schiano to tell you this as well? As irony always makes an appearance in sports, last Sunday’s game was the very first time Coach Schiano ever set foot on the field of MetLife Stadium since October 2010, when one of his own Rutgers players, Eric LeGrand, suffered a paralyzing injury while tackling a player from Army’s football team. Of all football coaches, Greg Schiano should know better than anyone about the risk of injury on a football field, and yet, this very coach showed zero sensitivity towards the safety of an opposing player, and a marquee player at that.
I’m not going to discuss Eric LeGrand’s life since his injury other than the fact that he’s become a far bigger celebrity in a wheelchair than he likely might’ve been as a football player, something that troubles me to no end. Certainly worthy of a future column, I can’t help but wonder if Eric LeGrand would be experiencing the same amount of national attention if he became paralyzed slipping on a bar of soap in the shower, or falling off a ladder, or being involved in a motor vehicle accident, or if he was playing a football game not televised by ESPN. Time may ultimately answer my nagging questions when another 20-year-old college football player fractures a cervical vertebra under less public circumstances, like recently injured Tulane defensive back Devon Walker.
Eric LeGrand’s new-found celebrity perhaps skews Coach Schiano’s perspective on injuries in football. Schiano admires LeGrand (an honorary Buccaneer, by the way) on such a grand level, gushing to the media about LeGrand’s book deals, radio gigs, TV appearances, telling the New York Daily News: “He’s really redirected his energy to his rehab and his future career.” What career?! LeGrand hadn’t even completed his junior year yet at Rutgers before he was injured; now he’s a media sensation. If Eric LeGrand never suffered an injury, he’d likely be a mid-round draft prospect at linebacker and possibly have completed his bachelors degree in communications. In other words, if it wasn’t for a very public and catastrophic injury, Eric LeGrand might be another struggling 23-year-old man trying to make the transition to adult contributor to our economy after four years of college. Eric LeGrand is the beneficiary of a sports culture that somehow became obligated to him, but I’m sure this is not the path this young man envisioned for himself at this stage of life.
That being said, Coach Schiano needs to understand that catastrophic career-ending football injuries don’t always end with a player receiving a lifetime of celebrity, attention and financial opportunity. What about Chucky Mullins who faded away in obscurity until death? How many people remember Mike Utley or Marc Buoniconti? How many people regularly see media stories about former players who recovered from paralysis, like Dennis Byrd or Adam Taliaferro? What about former athletes who are paralyzed but not as a result of football, like Tommy Urbanski? Perhaps Coach Schiano fails to understand that professional football players aren’t cheap and expendable like in the college ranks, and one major injury on a 53-man roster is more damaging to the success of a franchise than one major injury among 85 scholarship recipients. Regardless, Coach Schiano should respect the safety and well-being of every player, collegiate or professional, paid millions or merely receiving tuition and board, wearing your team’s uniform or the uniform of your opponent. Eric LeGrand’s injury supposedly affected Schiano so profoundly he still struggles for words when interviewed about it. If one young player’s injury could be that impactful, how could Schiano be so cavalier about potential injury to an opposing player? Is it because injuries matter only if suffered by your guys? Is Schiano’s sense of sportsmanship and empathy limited to his own team colors? Does Coach Schiano view NFL players through the same 47 percent prism Mitt Romney views American voters? The possible parallel is highly disturbing.
Mitt Romney can get away with such exclusionary thinking because we’ll likely never see him run for elected office as anything other than a Republican. On the other hand, Greg Schiano is a football coach, an athletic mercenary in a sport where loyalty and longevity are short-lived even though football players and coaches belong to a brotherhood created by competition. The Rutgers colors of 2011 become Buccaneer colors in 2012, and perhaps become colors of a different collegiate or professional organization in 2013, 2014 or some other year in the near future. If ever the day comes when Schiano interviews to wear the colors of the New York Giants, perhaps the organization should first inquire about his belief system regarding safety, injuries and kneel-down plays.
The world can be a much better place when we all care about each other regardless of our affiliations and beliefs.
Dave Pushkin is a former football player, scientist, and chemistry/physics professor, now working as an educational research consultant based in New Jersey. Disabled from a spinal injury since 2006, he writes about various issues in sports, science, politics, health care, and education.
Sunday, September 23, 2012
Tuesday, January 31, 2012
Fit to be tied about NFL OT rules -- Sports Thoughts for February 3, 2012
ALSO PUBLISHED AS GUEST CONTRIBUTOR FOR THE FOLLOWING BLOG SITE:
http://dunsonchecksin.com/cutting-ties-with-the-nfls-ot-rules/
As we approach Super Bowl XLVI, this recent post-season has introduced us to "non-sudden death" overtime rules, enacted by the NFL after the 2009 post-season in order to reduce the chances for a team losing in overtime by a field goal or "cheap" touchdown. What did we see this post-season, the first time to try these overtime rules out? The Denver Broncos beating the Pittsburgh Steelers on the first play of overtime in the AFC wild card round, an 80-yard touchdown pass against busted coverage, and the New York Giants punching their ticket for the Super Bowl with an overtime field goal in soggy San Francisco to win the NFC championship game over the 49ers.
Well... the league's intentions were good.
I argued this two years ago, and I'll argue it again: There was absolutely nothing wrong with post-season overtime rules, "sudden death" overtime, to begin with. What's "cheapened" overtime is using it during the regular season, something the NFL has done since 1974.
Yes, boys and girls too young to recall an NFL prior to the Pittsburgh Steelers ever winning a Super Bowl... there once was a time when NFL regular season games were only 60 minutes long, and games actually ended... in... TIES!
Well, the NFL owners didn't like ties, something about ties being like kissing your sister (hey... siblings can show affection for each other without things getting creepy) and the need to generate more fan excitement and interest. So, just like moving back the goalposts in 1973 and changing the kickoff line every decade, the owners decided 1973 would be the last season of "rampant ties" and fans going home from stadiums without having a definitive winner, even if it required an extra 15 minutes of play.
And that's how we've had "sudden death" overtime during the regular season these past 38 years.
Want to know how well it's worked, or perhaps made a significant improvement on the NFL game?
This past regular season gave us 13 overtime games, all resulting in winners. The most-frequent teams requiring overtime were the Arizona Cardinals (4 times), the Broncos and Dallas Cowboys (3 times each) -- and the Cardinals and Cowboys played each other in one overtime affair. That means that 9 of the 13 overtime games played this past season involved just three teams... three teams that all finished 8-8.
Think about it: the purpose of overtime is to yield a winner. What do we see? 69 percent of this season's overtime games involved just these three mediocre teams. These teams were mediocre with the benefit of overtime, which means that they were clearly mediocre if overtime didn't even exist. The Cardinals, Broncos and Cowboys all finished 8-8 with the benefit of overtime rules. If we turned the clock back to 1973 and played 60 minutes and not one second more, the Cardinals would've finished 4-8-4, the Broncos 5-8-3 and the Cowboys 6-7-3. Still think your teams had pretty good seasons? No... they had artificially inflated seasons because of overtime rules.
Fans might wonder if playing regular season games under pre-1974 rules impacted the divisional races and playoff seed. Believe it or not, only the AFC West would've produced a different divisional champion, the 8-6-2 San Diego Chargers. The Oakland Raiders would've finished second at 7-8-1, the Kansas City Chiefs would've finished third at 6-8-2, and the Broncos would've finished last. In fact, if we didn't have regular season overtime rules, the AFC West would've produced the same order of finish experts predicted prior to the season.
Warning to all those naive Broncos fans who think the 2011 season was the result of a divine miracle: the Broncos won their division because of luck, dumb luck, which is all regular season overtime boils down to!
In fact, with the exception of the AFC West, every other division and all other playoff seedings were completely unchanged. Heck, even the top three draft spots for 2012 are still the same: 1-Indianapolis Colts (2-14), 2-St. Louis Rams (2-13-1), 3-Minnesota Vikings (3-12-1).
The NFL played a total of 512 regular season games in 2011; 13 games required overtime. This translates to 2.5 percent of games requiring overtime. 2.5 percent is hardly anything; it's barely more than 1 percent according to OWS aficionados. So for such a small percentage, why does the NFL bother with regular season overtime, risking additional injuries to players beyond the risk of playing 60 minute games? There must be more logic than to give mediocre teams less mediocre-looking records, right?
Let's turn the clock back to 1973 and see what pre-overtime regular season records looked like then. Keep in mind that we only had 26 NFL teams and each one played a 14-game regular season. Of 364 regular season games played in 1973 there were 7 ties. SEVEN, accounting for 1.9 percent of all games played.
Which teams were the "tie kings"? The 5-7-2 Green Bay Packers, the 7-5-2 Cleveland Browns, 7-5-2 Kansas City Chiefs, and the 7-5-2 Denver Broncos (no, Tim Tebow wasn't their quarterback). It shouldn't be too surprising to know that 6 of the 7 tie games in 1973 involved either the Packers, Browns, Chiefs or Broncos, since teams that play to ties tend to play to ties with other teams that play to ties.
Got that? Good! Pop quiz at the end of this column!
Okay, so 1973 doesn't seem as tied up as 2011, does it? Perhaps tie games were a chronic problem leading up to 1973 and a decision needed to be made with expansion teams and a 16-game schedule in the future?
In 1972, 5 of 364 regular season games ended in ties, 1.4 percent of all games.
In 1971, 8 of 364 regular season games ended in ties, 2.2 percent of all games.
In 1970, 9 of 364 regular season games ended in ties, 2.7 percent of all games.
So, for the first four seasons after the AFL-NFL merger, a total of 1,456 regular season games were played, 29 ended in ties, accounting for 2.0 percent of all games. This is quite comparable to this recent season. Were any particular teams playing to tie games at a somewhat prolific rate? The Raiders finished 8-4-2 in 1970 and 1971; they played in 6 tie games during the 4-year post-merger period, 10.7 percent of 56 total games played by one team.
The Chiefs finished 7-5-2 in 1970 and 1973; they played in 5 tie games during 1970-1973, as did the Chargers (including 3 during a 5-6-3 1970 season). This accounted for 8.9 percent of games played by each team.
The Packers finished 4-8-2 in 1971 and 5-7-2 in 1973; they played in 4 tie games during 1970-1973. The Broncos also played in 4 tie games during 1970-1973, as did the New Orleans Saints (including 4-8-2 in 1971), the Philadelphia Eagles (one tie each season) and the then-St. Louis Cardinals (one tie each season). This accounted for 7.1 percent of games played by each team.
The Detroit Lions, then-Los Angeles Rams and Atlanta Falcons all played in 3 tie games during 1970-1973, accounting for 5.3 percent of games played by each team.
League-wide, tie games were relatively rare, but for 11 of the NFL's 26 teams, tie games occurred more than twice as often, and that's where the problem appeared to be. Of the 29 tie games played between 1970 and 1973, 11 teams accounted for 20 of those tie games, the same 69 percent Denver, Dallas and Arizona accounted for in 2011overtime games.
Were tie games a problem before the 1970 merger? It depends on how you look at it. During the ten seasons leading up to the merger (1960-1969), the NFL played a grand total of 2,018 regular season games - first starting with 13 teams playing a 12-game schedule, then having 16 teams playing a 14-game schedule. 48 games ended in ties, accounting for 2.4 percent of all games played.
However, the 1967 season (the first involving all 16 teams after the Saints joined as an expansion team) resulted in 9 ties, accounting for 4.0 percent of 224 games played. An amazing 6 of those tie games involved two teams, the 5-6-3 Washington Redskins and the 3-8-3 Minnesota Vikings. Two other teams, the Rams and the then-Baltimore Colts, each finished 11-1-2, but the Rams won the Coastal Division title by virtue of tying the Colts early in the season then defeating the Colts in the regular season finale, the Colts only loss of the season.
FYI: in 1963, the Chicago Bears won the NFL western divisional crown with an 11-1-2 record, besting the 11-2-1 Packers, denying Green Bay the opportunity to be the first three-peat NFL champion. That same year, the Steelers finished 7-4-3.
Three ties is the most any team has ever had during a single regular season since the 1932 Bears finished 7-1-6, the season prior to the NFL playing championship games.
During the 10-year history of the American Football League, a total of 1,204 regular season games were played, 24 ending in ties (2.0 percent of all games played). The most tie games in any single season was 5 in 1965 (4.0 percent of 112 games played by 8 teams), led by the western division champion Chargers who finished 9-2-3.
Looking at the grand scheme of things, the overall rate of overtime games in 2011 is very comparable to the rate of tie games played in the pre-merger NFL, AFL and post-merger combined NFL during 1960-1973. Has overtime necessarily changed the rate of games ending tied after 60 minutes? Not necessarily, but overtime has managed to mask mediocrity a little better compared to what we saw with teams having two or more ties during seasons of the 1960s and early 1970s. The reality is that ties and overtime games are historically more prevalent among a predominant minority of teams in any given season, and the advent of regular season overtime really hasn't eliminated the prevalent mediocrity among these teams more than forcing someone to ultimately win or lose tie games and make league standings and won-loss records more consistent looking.
That's really not reason enough for an extra quarter of play during the regular season. Let’s stop tinkering around with “sudden death” and return it to its rightful place, the NFL postseason, when losers go home. Let’s go back to the regular season rules of 1973, when games end in ties and each team has future Sundays to look towards.
http://dunsonchecksin.com/cutting-ties-with-the-nfls-ot-rules/
As we approach Super Bowl XLVI, this recent post-season has introduced us to "non-sudden death" overtime rules, enacted by the NFL after the 2009 post-season in order to reduce the chances for a team losing in overtime by a field goal or "cheap" touchdown. What did we see this post-season, the first time to try these overtime rules out? The Denver Broncos beating the Pittsburgh Steelers on the first play of overtime in the AFC wild card round, an 80-yard touchdown pass against busted coverage, and the New York Giants punching their ticket for the Super Bowl with an overtime field goal in soggy San Francisco to win the NFC championship game over the 49ers.
Well... the league's intentions were good.
I argued this two years ago, and I'll argue it again: There was absolutely nothing wrong with post-season overtime rules, "sudden death" overtime, to begin with. What's "cheapened" overtime is using it during the regular season, something the NFL has done since 1974.
Yes, boys and girls too young to recall an NFL prior to the Pittsburgh Steelers ever winning a Super Bowl... there once was a time when NFL regular season games were only 60 minutes long, and games actually ended... in... TIES!
Well, the NFL owners didn't like ties, something about ties being like kissing your sister (hey... siblings can show affection for each other without things getting creepy) and the need to generate more fan excitement and interest. So, just like moving back the goalposts in 1973 and changing the kickoff line every decade, the owners decided 1973 would be the last season of "rampant ties" and fans going home from stadiums without having a definitive winner, even if it required an extra 15 minutes of play.
And that's how we've had "sudden death" overtime during the regular season these past 38 years.
Want to know how well it's worked, or perhaps made a significant improvement on the NFL game?
This past regular season gave us 13 overtime games, all resulting in winners. The most-frequent teams requiring overtime were the Arizona Cardinals (4 times), the Broncos and Dallas Cowboys (3 times each) -- and the Cardinals and Cowboys played each other in one overtime affair. That means that 9 of the 13 overtime games played this past season involved just three teams... three teams that all finished 8-8.
Think about it: the purpose of overtime is to yield a winner. What do we see? 69 percent of this season's overtime games involved just these three mediocre teams. These teams were mediocre with the benefit of overtime, which means that they were clearly mediocre if overtime didn't even exist. The Cardinals, Broncos and Cowboys all finished 8-8 with the benefit of overtime rules. If we turned the clock back to 1973 and played 60 minutes and not one second more, the Cardinals would've finished 4-8-4, the Broncos 5-8-3 and the Cowboys 6-7-3. Still think your teams had pretty good seasons? No... they had artificially inflated seasons because of overtime rules.
Fans might wonder if playing regular season games under pre-1974 rules impacted the divisional races and playoff seed. Believe it or not, only the AFC West would've produced a different divisional champion, the 8-6-2 San Diego Chargers. The Oakland Raiders would've finished second at 7-8-1, the Kansas City Chiefs would've finished third at 6-8-2, and the Broncos would've finished last. In fact, if we didn't have regular season overtime rules, the AFC West would've produced the same order of finish experts predicted prior to the season.
Warning to all those naive Broncos fans who think the 2011 season was the result of a divine miracle: the Broncos won their division because of luck, dumb luck, which is all regular season overtime boils down to!
In fact, with the exception of the AFC West, every other division and all other playoff seedings were completely unchanged. Heck, even the top three draft spots for 2012 are still the same: 1-Indianapolis Colts (2-14), 2-St. Louis Rams (2-13-1), 3-Minnesota Vikings (3-12-1).
The NFL played a total of 512 regular season games in 2011; 13 games required overtime. This translates to 2.5 percent of games requiring overtime. 2.5 percent is hardly anything; it's barely more than 1 percent according to OWS aficionados. So for such a small percentage, why does the NFL bother with regular season overtime, risking additional injuries to players beyond the risk of playing 60 minute games? There must be more logic than to give mediocre teams less mediocre-looking records, right?
Let's turn the clock back to 1973 and see what pre-overtime regular season records looked like then. Keep in mind that we only had 26 NFL teams and each one played a 14-game regular season. Of 364 regular season games played in 1973 there were 7 ties. SEVEN, accounting for 1.9 percent of all games played.
Which teams were the "tie kings"? The 5-7-2 Green Bay Packers, the 7-5-2 Cleveland Browns, 7-5-2 Kansas City Chiefs, and the 7-5-2 Denver Broncos (no, Tim Tebow wasn't their quarterback). It shouldn't be too surprising to know that 6 of the 7 tie games in 1973 involved either the Packers, Browns, Chiefs or Broncos, since teams that play to ties tend to play to ties with other teams that play to ties.
Got that? Good! Pop quiz at the end of this column!
Okay, so 1973 doesn't seem as tied up as 2011, does it? Perhaps tie games were a chronic problem leading up to 1973 and a decision needed to be made with expansion teams and a 16-game schedule in the future?
In 1972, 5 of 364 regular season games ended in ties, 1.4 percent of all games.
In 1971, 8 of 364 regular season games ended in ties, 2.2 percent of all games.
In 1970, 9 of 364 regular season games ended in ties, 2.7 percent of all games.
So, for the first four seasons after the AFL-NFL merger, a total of 1,456 regular season games were played, 29 ended in ties, accounting for 2.0 percent of all games. This is quite comparable to this recent season. Were any particular teams playing to tie games at a somewhat prolific rate? The Raiders finished 8-4-2 in 1970 and 1971; they played in 6 tie games during the 4-year post-merger period, 10.7 percent of 56 total games played by one team.
The Chiefs finished 7-5-2 in 1970 and 1973; they played in 5 tie games during 1970-1973, as did the Chargers (including 3 during a 5-6-3 1970 season). This accounted for 8.9 percent of games played by each team.
The Packers finished 4-8-2 in 1971 and 5-7-2 in 1973; they played in 4 tie games during 1970-1973. The Broncos also played in 4 tie games during 1970-1973, as did the New Orleans Saints (including 4-8-2 in 1971), the Philadelphia Eagles (one tie each season) and the then-St. Louis Cardinals (one tie each season). This accounted for 7.1 percent of games played by each team.
The Detroit Lions, then-Los Angeles Rams and Atlanta Falcons all played in 3 tie games during 1970-1973, accounting for 5.3 percent of games played by each team.
League-wide, tie games were relatively rare, but for 11 of the NFL's 26 teams, tie games occurred more than twice as often, and that's where the problem appeared to be. Of the 29 tie games played between 1970 and 1973, 11 teams accounted for 20 of those tie games, the same 69 percent Denver, Dallas and Arizona accounted for in 2011overtime games.
Were tie games a problem before the 1970 merger? It depends on how you look at it. During the ten seasons leading up to the merger (1960-1969), the NFL played a grand total of 2,018 regular season games - first starting with 13 teams playing a 12-game schedule, then having 16 teams playing a 14-game schedule. 48 games ended in ties, accounting for 2.4 percent of all games played.
However, the 1967 season (the first involving all 16 teams after the Saints joined as an expansion team) resulted in 9 ties, accounting for 4.0 percent of 224 games played. An amazing 6 of those tie games involved two teams, the 5-6-3 Washington Redskins and the 3-8-3 Minnesota Vikings. Two other teams, the Rams and the then-Baltimore Colts, each finished 11-1-2, but the Rams won the Coastal Division title by virtue of tying the Colts early in the season then defeating the Colts in the regular season finale, the Colts only loss of the season.
FYI: in 1963, the Chicago Bears won the NFL western divisional crown with an 11-1-2 record, besting the 11-2-1 Packers, denying Green Bay the opportunity to be the first three-peat NFL champion. That same year, the Steelers finished 7-4-3.
Three ties is the most any team has ever had during a single regular season since the 1932 Bears finished 7-1-6, the season prior to the NFL playing championship games.
During the 10-year history of the American Football League, a total of 1,204 regular season games were played, 24 ending in ties (2.0 percent of all games played). The most tie games in any single season was 5 in 1965 (4.0 percent of 112 games played by 8 teams), led by the western division champion Chargers who finished 9-2-3.
Looking at the grand scheme of things, the overall rate of overtime games in 2011 is very comparable to the rate of tie games played in the pre-merger NFL, AFL and post-merger combined NFL during 1960-1973. Has overtime necessarily changed the rate of games ending tied after 60 minutes? Not necessarily, but overtime has managed to mask mediocrity a little better compared to what we saw with teams having two or more ties during seasons of the 1960s and early 1970s. The reality is that ties and overtime games are historically more prevalent among a predominant minority of teams in any given season, and the advent of regular season overtime really hasn't eliminated the prevalent mediocrity among these teams more than forcing someone to ultimately win or lose tie games and make league standings and won-loss records more consistent looking.
That's really not reason enough for an extra quarter of play during the regular season. Let’s stop tinkering around with “sudden death” and return it to its rightful place, the NFL postseason, when losers go home. Let’s go back to the regular season rules of 1973, when games end in ties and each team has future Sundays to look towards.
Friday, December 2, 2011
Does ESPN pine for the Confederacy? Oy, Let’s hope not! -- Doc’s Sports Thoughts for December 2, 2011
As December begins, all four major professional sports angle for our attention. College football teams are wrapping up regular seasons, starting conference playoffs and securing bowl invitations. The NFL regular season is heading into its homestretch, and with five weeks to go, we’re starting to see potential playoff seedings for both the AFC and NFC. Now that America is in the season of shopping and giving, underachieving college and professional football teams are processing pink slips for coaches and dreaming towards better replacements and blue-chip draft picks for next season. The NBA lockout is presumably over, giving Americans one more thing to look forward to on December 25th. The NHL season is in full bloom, including a return to action by Sidney Crosby, healthy again for the Pittsburgh Penguins. Even Major League Baseball provides us reasons to look ahead to Spring Training, with a new labor deal extension, hot stove action, and the recent hiring of Bobby Valentine by the Boston Red Sox, bringing a new managerial energy.
I start today’s column on a rather odd note, and as the title of this column suggests, something seems amiss at ESPN. For those who don’t know, ESPN, the world’s largest sports cable network, is based in Bristol, Connecticut. However, if you watch enough of ESPN programming, you’d swear or at least wonder if ESPN’s thinking process is rooted south of the Mason-Dixon Line. No, I’m not talking about NASCAR and rednecks racing cars around tracks at breakneck speeds. I’m talking about ESPN employees openly pontificating from their Good Ol’ Dixie frame of reference. The ESPN employee? Skip Bayless, a former columnist with the Dallas Morning News, now a regular talking head panelist on ESPN’s First Take, seen Monday-Friday, 10:00am-12:00noon on ESPN2.
Bayless (AKA “The Bloviator” by fellow ESPN panelist Stephen A. Smith) has been a one-man pom-pom brigade for Denver Broncos “quarterback” Tim Tebow. I place the term “quarterback” in quotes because I frankly don’t believe Tebow has the physical build, upper-body mechanics, or the thinking intellect to be a starting quarterback running today’s sophisticated NFL offensive schemes. It’s a fairly simple assessment, one I’ve made in previous columns and still stand by: Tebow is too muscle-bound, too bulky and disproportioned in his muscle mass to throw a football with consistent effectiveness as a left-handed passer. It has nothing to do with passing from the pocket or on the run but has everything to do with how his arms and legs are coordinated in his passing motion. When your first mental instinct is to always tuck the ball under your arm and run like a halfback or fullback you will always look awkward trying to throw a football left-handed. This isn’t a debate about football philosophy; it’s a fact based on anatomy, physiology and physics.
If you don’t believe me, try imitating, physically or mentally, one of your favorite right-handed baseball pitchers, past or present, with really pronounced body mechanics and wind-up: Luis Tiant, Tom Seaver, Kent Tekulve, Nolan Ryan, Dwight Gooden, Bronson Arroyo, or perhaps Mariano Rivera. Got a physical or mental feel for how these guys pitched a baseball? Now try doing it LEFT-HANDED. Let me know how many times you fall down or spin yourself dizzy into the ground. Better yet, now let’s think of some lefties with pronounced mechanics: Tug McGraw? Fernando Valenzuela? Johan Santana? Ever really watch how David Wells pitched years ago? How about observing C.C. Sabathia? Any chance a right-hander could imitate those left-handed motions?
Pitching a baseball and passing a football both work on similar mechanical principles. As a consequence of those principles, a successful left-handed quarterback’s motion generally has to be pass-first in orientation, even if he’s rolling out after taking the snap from center. Right-handed quarterbacks don’t have this same issue to battle, which is why they can still pass effectively when rolling to their opposite side. No matter which direction a right-handed quarterback rolls, he can throw a legitimate NFL-quality pass downfield. If a left-handed quarterback rolls to his right, he’s at a greater disadvantage because he has to physically adjust his body position, and arm angle, in order to throw — in other words, lefties don’t throw on the run well rolling to their opposite side.
Am I the first person to point out these things regarding Tim Tebow’s physical limitations as an NFL quarterback? No, although I might be the first to present the argument by integrating football, baseball and science. Tim Tebow has several critics, and we all making similar arguments.
But Tebow doesn’t have a supporter quite like Skip Bayless. To put it bluntly, Bayless is unabashed, nonobjective, and biased in his public support. At first I wondered if his support was simply to be the lone contrarian among the naysayers. Bayless has stated several times that he doesn’t believe Tebow will ever win a passing title or earn a Pro Bowl spot, but he firmly believes Tebow will ultimately lead the Denver Broncos to the playoffs and possibly a Super Bowl title. In other words, Bayless believes Tebow’s a winner and the Broncos will be winners with him leading them into battle. At the moment it’s hard to argue against Bayless’ predictions. The Broncos are 5-1 this season with Tebow the starting quarterback, and 6-3 going back to last season. This looks a lot better than the 4-14 record Kyle Orton (now a Kansas City Chief) compiled the past two seasons. Although Tebow completes only 45.5% of his pass attempts, he has passed for 8 touchdowns against only one interception these past six weeks, and has rushed for 455 yards and 3 touchdowns to boot. The 6-5 Broncos are only one game behind the Oakland Raiders in the AFC Western division race, as well as one game behind the Cincinnati Bengals for the final AFC wild card spot, so anything’s possible.
But simply changing quarterbacks wasn’t good enough for Bayless. No, because Tebow cannot master today’s NFL offensive schemes, Bayless demanded that head coach John Fox and Executive Vice-President of Football Operations, John Elway, the Broncos’ former Hall-of-Fame quarterback (1983-1998), completely change their offensive scheme to tailor to Tebow’s strengths, which are primarily running the ball, playing out of a hurry-up shotgun formation, and throwing passes to receivers when defenses blow coverage assignments. Because winning is the name of the game, Fox and Elway switched to an option-based scheme (AKA “wishbone” or “veer” in college football). The results speak for themselves. The Broncos are 5-1 after a 1-4 start. They run the ball more than 65% of the time. They pass only when needed or if opportunity presents itself. Is it effective? Relative to the first month of the season, yes. Relative to competing against upper-echelon NFL offenses, the jury’s still out. The Broncos have benefited from playing slog-type games against opponents that struggled against a continuously improving defense. In four games, the Broncos were within a touchdown going into the fourth quarter. Opposing defenses eventually wore down trying to stop such a run-oriented offense, and the Broncos came back to win all five games in the fourth quarter or overtime.
Okay, so what’s the problem? NFL team switches quarterback, offensive scheme, and his biggest media supporter is enjoying the biggest and most-satisfying laugh right now. Well, with Tim Tebow, nothing is simply a matter of football, because he’s a Fundamental Christian and very public and vocal about it. Nothing can be discussed with this young man, a young man I knew absolutely nothing about, nor cared about, prior to 2007, when he won the Heisman Trophy at the University of Florida. Despite having lived and worked in Florida for ten years during the 1980s and 1990s, I have very little interest in Southeastern Conference sports, and the further I’m removed from my college football days (now 30 years and counting), the less interest I have in college football, the Heisman hype, as well as the BCS system. If I watched Tim Tebow play quarterback for U-of-F more than five times prior to the 2010 NFL draft, that was a lot. But I saw enough on television to recognize his flaws at the quarterback position and recommend he not be drafted as a quarterback, and certainly not in the first round, which the Broncos did on both counts.
Contrary to Bayless’ contention that we’re all “Tebow Haters” if we have and express doubts about Tebow’s ability to play quarterback in the NFL, or are rubbed wrong by this young man’s incessant in-your-face presentation about his religious faith, I’m personally rubbed wrong by the entire Tebow package: his ability to play quarterback, his continuous interjection of Right-wing Christianity, his arrogant demands before the 2010 NFL draft that teams only draft him as a quarterback, his public inability to consider the possibility that he might have to switch positions in order to play in the NFL, the marketing machine that advised him to produce an anti-abortion commercial with his mother to be televised during the 2010 Super Bowl (before he was even drafted), the public frenzy his fans and supporters like Bayless whipped themselves into, forcing the struggling Broncos, under a new head coach and front office, to dump Orton as their quarterback, bypass experienced backup Brady Quinn, and insert a bench-riding Tebow into the starting job, change the entire offensive scheme for him, and trading off or waiving an endless list of talented receivers who didn’t feel comfortable playing with Tebow as part of a gimmick, publicity stunt, and popularity contest among fans and supporters who look to this young man as the second coming, the wondrous sign of their “Rapture”, and the great shining hope of some Bible-Belt revival meeting.
Yes, the entire package offends me as a social liberal, former football player, mature, middle-aged and accomplished adult, and as a Jewish-American. While I’ve always advocated social awareness and a sense of conviction among our professional athletes, I also expect that if one is going to spout off in public, one should be able to discuss, or be respectful of, both sides of an issue. I don’t see that attribute with Tebow or his supporters. Like all fundamentalists, their view is all or nothing, and they preach it accordingly. I’ve also advocated that our professional athletes bring some humility to the public forum when they make the transition from collegiate sports. I also don’t see that with Tebow and his supporters who seem to think starting NFL quarterback is Tebow’s divine birthright, and anyone who dare suggest a different position (e.g., running back or tight end) commits biblical blasphemy. It takes more than a lot of chutzpah to demand what your job description should be before you’ve been fully evaluated, drafted and signed by an NFL team. The NFL didn’t and never owed anything to this young man and his supporters. Team Tebow knew well in advanced the questions being raised about his ability to play quarterback. Lord knows it wasn’t and will not be the first time NFL scouts and coaches had doubts about U-of-F or SEC quarterbacks, Heisman winners or not. But Team Tebow insisted starting NFL quarterback was the Lord’s mission.
Lastly, for those who admire Tebow’s commitment to faith (and that includes me, to a limited degree), what if the quarterback’s name was Chaim Lipschitz, a rebel kid from Crown Heights who dropped out of a Yeshiva to learn about and play football at a Big East program like Rutgers? What if Rutgers had to petition to the Big East and NCAA to ensure all their games were played on Thursdays? What if Mr. Lipschitz was a bearded version of Dan Marino inside the stadium and looked like he should be working in the Diamond District outside the stadium? What if ESPN interviewed him before the draft and he started quoting from the Talmud? What if the team drafting him found out he couldn’t play for an entire month of the regular season because games conflicted with Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur and Sukkot?
And this brings us to Mr. Skip Bayless, ESPN’s version of Anne Coulter. Here’s a man who’s so blindly supportive of Tim Tebow that he actually told Stephen A. Smith during a First Take debate that Tebow was being “discriminated” against for being a running quarterback, just like Michael Vick and Vince Young. I was just as incredulous as Smith was when Bayless offered this theory. Vick and Young are African-American quarterbacks, and that’s why they were discriminated against, just like Donovan McNabb, Warren Moon, and Doug Williams were. These men weren’t discriminated because of their ability or inability to run; they were discriminated on the basis of their race and presumed lack of intellect. Now, I will go on the record and say that neither Michael Vick nor Vince Young have the intellect to be successful NFL quarterbacks like many other quarterbacks are and have been, but I also have that same assessment for Tim Tebow. Vick, Young and Tebow can’t hold a candle to McNabb or Moon, not to mention Steve Young, Joe Montana, or John Elway when it comes to intellect about the game as well as the ability to run and pass. The ability to play NFL quarterback is a function of talent and smarts, not the color of one’s skin.
That a veteran sportswriter like Bayless would even utter the notion that Tebow is some kind of persecution victim not only shows a complete lack of understanding about what “discrimination” even means, but demonstrates why our continuously evolving and diversifying nation continues to polarize worse and worse. Does Tebow represent some kind of “getting back America” mentality that white, fundamental Christians have been yammering about since the 2008 presidential election? Yes, I think there’s some element to that, but one only need to listen to more of Bayless’ “bloviating” to see something more troubling and hypocritical.
Surprisingly, Bayless advocates for Michael Vick and Vince Young as running quarterbacks, so Bayless isn’t necessarily using race as his lens, even though he doesn’t completely understand how to use race in the first place. But Bayless is not necessarily an advocate of Donovan McNabb, an African-American (and a proud and dignified one) quarterback who used to be a good runner. After McNabb was granted his release by the Minnesota Vikings yesterday, Bayless commented that McNabb was “out of shape” towards the end of his tenure with the Philadelphia Eagles, when he reported to the Washington Redskins last year (after the Eagles traded him), and when he reported to the Vikings for training camp this year. Bayless questioned McNabb’s conditioning and commitment to playing football after a 12-year NFL career. While some folks might agree with Bayless’ view and see nothing more to it, I’m not among them.
It’s no secret that as this NFL season has progressed, Bayless has been extremely vocal in his distain for Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers. Despite last season’s Super Bowl championship and this season’s 11-0 start and Rodgers statistics (127.7 QB rating, 33 TDs, 4 INTs, almost 3500 yards passing), Bayless swears by New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady (105.5 QB rating, 28 TDs, 10 INTs, over 3600 yards passing) as the Most-Valuable Player. This is highly confusing but not impossible to decipher.
We need to begin with a basic question: what does Bayless have against Aaron Rodgers in Green Bay? Well, first we must appreciate that Rodgers’ younger brother, Jordan, plays quarterback for Vanderbilt University, which happens to be Bayless’ alma mater, located in Nashville, Tennessee. Bayless thinks the world of the younger Rodgers but routinely criticizes the elder one, who went to college at the University of California-Berkeley. Rodgers was a first-round draft pick of the Packers in 2005. He spent three seasons on the bench while the Packers were quarterbacked by Brett Favre. Remember him? One day in 2008, Ol’ Brett retired to his farm in Hattiesburg, Mississippi, and Rodgers inherited the quarterback job. Then Brett changed his mind and came out of retirement. Then the Packers traded Brett to the New York Jets, and... You know the rest of the story leading up to Brett’s most-recent retired status in 2011.
Brett Favre was one of Bayless’ favorites, a good ol’ boy from the heart of Dixie. Yeah, Brett drank, raised hell and played by the seat of his pants. And, boy, Ol’ Brett sure could run around and throw like the best of them, despite his lack of self-discipline. He was the 1990s version of Bobby Layne and Buddy Parker, two redneck quarterbacks who excited fans during the 1950s. If you watched Brett play the last three years of his career, he looked rather paunchy and unconditioned wearing a Jets uniform in 2008 and a Vikings uniform in 2009 and 2010, and it showed as each season moved along from September to December. He looked old. His behavior was erratic. He looked tired. He looked beaten up. He looked washed up. He played injured, costing his teams while he padded his Hall of Fame resume. More often than not, Brett Favre came out on the right end of the scoreboard, which is one of many reasons for his eventual enshrinement in Canton. But the Packers discarded this noble Prince of the South before Brett and his fans thought the time was right, making Aaron Rodgers an enemy of the Rebel Flag.
So now we can connect some dots: Skip Bayless gushes over Brett Favre, Michael Vick, Vince Young and Tim Tebow, and even Jordan Rodgers, but not Donovan McNabb (a Chicago native who played college football for Syracuse) or Aaron Rodgers. This may be but a limited sample of Skip Bayless, but might we be shocked to go through his publishing and social media archives and see mostly positive support for quarterbacks like Phillip Rivers, Jay Cutler, the Manning brothers, the late Steve McNair, Tony Romo and Drew Brees — quarterbacks who either grew up in the South, played college football in the South, or play for Southern-state NFL teams? Might we conversely notice mostly negative support towards quarterbacks like Steve Young (Connecticut native, graduate of BYU in Utah), Mark Sanchez (Southern California native, played at USC) or even Matt Hasselbach (Massachusetts native, graduate of Boston College)?
It’s just a thought, but perhaps Skip Bayless wears more than his support of Tim Tebow on his sleeve, and is incapable of socio-political neutrality. If Bayless was specifically an employee of some southern pep squad, perhaps his blatant bias would be both understandable and acceptable, but Bayless is a journalist, and paid to maintain the standards of neutrality for a cable network that does not act in any politically-driven capacity. If Bayless’ heart is that entrenched in the heart of Dixie, then perhaps ESPN should relocate him geographically to his own private studio where his loyalties and commitment to objectivity are. Again, ask yourself how Bayless would represent ESPN if the Denver Broncos quarterback’s name was Chaim Lipschitz.
Reminder — Don’t forget my new book is available (and on sale) in both paperback and eBook (PDF) format at Lulu.com.
Contact me for further discounts or coupon information. Buy and read it because you want something to THINK about.
Philosophy of “Packer” Pedagogy:
Vince Lombardi, critical thinking and problem-based learning
I start today’s column on a rather odd note, and as the title of this column suggests, something seems amiss at ESPN. For those who don’t know, ESPN, the world’s largest sports cable network, is based in Bristol, Connecticut. However, if you watch enough of ESPN programming, you’d swear or at least wonder if ESPN’s thinking process is rooted south of the Mason-Dixon Line. No, I’m not talking about NASCAR and rednecks racing cars around tracks at breakneck speeds. I’m talking about ESPN employees openly pontificating from their Good Ol’ Dixie frame of reference. The ESPN employee? Skip Bayless, a former columnist with the Dallas Morning News, now a regular talking head panelist on ESPN’s First Take, seen Monday-Friday, 10:00am-12:00noon on ESPN2.
Bayless (AKA “The Bloviator” by fellow ESPN panelist Stephen A. Smith) has been a one-man pom-pom brigade for Denver Broncos “quarterback” Tim Tebow. I place the term “quarterback” in quotes because I frankly don’t believe Tebow has the physical build, upper-body mechanics, or the thinking intellect to be a starting quarterback running today’s sophisticated NFL offensive schemes. It’s a fairly simple assessment, one I’ve made in previous columns and still stand by: Tebow is too muscle-bound, too bulky and disproportioned in his muscle mass to throw a football with consistent effectiveness as a left-handed passer. It has nothing to do with passing from the pocket or on the run but has everything to do with how his arms and legs are coordinated in his passing motion. When your first mental instinct is to always tuck the ball under your arm and run like a halfback or fullback you will always look awkward trying to throw a football left-handed. This isn’t a debate about football philosophy; it’s a fact based on anatomy, physiology and physics.
If you don’t believe me, try imitating, physically or mentally, one of your favorite right-handed baseball pitchers, past or present, with really pronounced body mechanics and wind-up: Luis Tiant, Tom Seaver, Kent Tekulve, Nolan Ryan, Dwight Gooden, Bronson Arroyo, or perhaps Mariano Rivera. Got a physical or mental feel for how these guys pitched a baseball? Now try doing it LEFT-HANDED. Let me know how many times you fall down or spin yourself dizzy into the ground. Better yet, now let’s think of some lefties with pronounced mechanics: Tug McGraw? Fernando Valenzuela? Johan Santana? Ever really watch how David Wells pitched years ago? How about observing C.C. Sabathia? Any chance a right-hander could imitate those left-handed motions?
Pitching a baseball and passing a football both work on similar mechanical principles. As a consequence of those principles, a successful left-handed quarterback’s motion generally has to be pass-first in orientation, even if he’s rolling out after taking the snap from center. Right-handed quarterbacks don’t have this same issue to battle, which is why they can still pass effectively when rolling to their opposite side. No matter which direction a right-handed quarterback rolls, he can throw a legitimate NFL-quality pass downfield. If a left-handed quarterback rolls to his right, he’s at a greater disadvantage because he has to physically adjust his body position, and arm angle, in order to throw — in other words, lefties don’t throw on the run well rolling to their opposite side.
Am I the first person to point out these things regarding Tim Tebow’s physical limitations as an NFL quarterback? No, although I might be the first to present the argument by integrating football, baseball and science. Tim Tebow has several critics, and we all making similar arguments.
But Tebow doesn’t have a supporter quite like Skip Bayless. To put it bluntly, Bayless is unabashed, nonobjective, and biased in his public support. At first I wondered if his support was simply to be the lone contrarian among the naysayers. Bayless has stated several times that he doesn’t believe Tebow will ever win a passing title or earn a Pro Bowl spot, but he firmly believes Tebow will ultimately lead the Denver Broncos to the playoffs and possibly a Super Bowl title. In other words, Bayless believes Tebow’s a winner and the Broncos will be winners with him leading them into battle. At the moment it’s hard to argue against Bayless’ predictions. The Broncos are 5-1 this season with Tebow the starting quarterback, and 6-3 going back to last season. This looks a lot better than the 4-14 record Kyle Orton (now a Kansas City Chief) compiled the past two seasons. Although Tebow completes only 45.5% of his pass attempts, he has passed for 8 touchdowns against only one interception these past six weeks, and has rushed for 455 yards and 3 touchdowns to boot. The 6-5 Broncos are only one game behind the Oakland Raiders in the AFC Western division race, as well as one game behind the Cincinnati Bengals for the final AFC wild card spot, so anything’s possible.
But simply changing quarterbacks wasn’t good enough for Bayless. No, because Tebow cannot master today’s NFL offensive schemes, Bayless demanded that head coach John Fox and Executive Vice-President of Football Operations, John Elway, the Broncos’ former Hall-of-Fame quarterback (1983-1998), completely change their offensive scheme to tailor to Tebow’s strengths, which are primarily running the ball, playing out of a hurry-up shotgun formation, and throwing passes to receivers when defenses blow coverage assignments. Because winning is the name of the game, Fox and Elway switched to an option-based scheme (AKA “wishbone” or “veer” in college football). The results speak for themselves. The Broncos are 5-1 after a 1-4 start. They run the ball more than 65% of the time. They pass only when needed or if opportunity presents itself. Is it effective? Relative to the first month of the season, yes. Relative to competing against upper-echelon NFL offenses, the jury’s still out. The Broncos have benefited from playing slog-type games against opponents that struggled against a continuously improving defense. In four games, the Broncos were within a touchdown going into the fourth quarter. Opposing defenses eventually wore down trying to stop such a run-oriented offense, and the Broncos came back to win all five games in the fourth quarter or overtime.
Okay, so what’s the problem? NFL team switches quarterback, offensive scheme, and his biggest media supporter is enjoying the biggest and most-satisfying laugh right now. Well, with Tim Tebow, nothing is simply a matter of football, because he’s a Fundamental Christian and very public and vocal about it. Nothing can be discussed with this young man, a young man I knew absolutely nothing about, nor cared about, prior to 2007, when he won the Heisman Trophy at the University of Florida. Despite having lived and worked in Florida for ten years during the 1980s and 1990s, I have very little interest in Southeastern Conference sports, and the further I’m removed from my college football days (now 30 years and counting), the less interest I have in college football, the Heisman hype, as well as the BCS system. If I watched Tim Tebow play quarterback for U-of-F more than five times prior to the 2010 NFL draft, that was a lot. But I saw enough on television to recognize his flaws at the quarterback position and recommend he not be drafted as a quarterback, and certainly not in the first round, which the Broncos did on both counts.
Contrary to Bayless’ contention that we’re all “Tebow Haters” if we have and express doubts about Tebow’s ability to play quarterback in the NFL, or are rubbed wrong by this young man’s incessant in-your-face presentation about his religious faith, I’m personally rubbed wrong by the entire Tebow package: his ability to play quarterback, his continuous interjection of Right-wing Christianity, his arrogant demands before the 2010 NFL draft that teams only draft him as a quarterback, his public inability to consider the possibility that he might have to switch positions in order to play in the NFL, the marketing machine that advised him to produce an anti-abortion commercial with his mother to be televised during the 2010 Super Bowl (before he was even drafted), the public frenzy his fans and supporters like Bayless whipped themselves into, forcing the struggling Broncos, under a new head coach and front office, to dump Orton as their quarterback, bypass experienced backup Brady Quinn, and insert a bench-riding Tebow into the starting job, change the entire offensive scheme for him, and trading off or waiving an endless list of talented receivers who didn’t feel comfortable playing with Tebow as part of a gimmick, publicity stunt, and popularity contest among fans and supporters who look to this young man as the second coming, the wondrous sign of their “Rapture”, and the great shining hope of some Bible-Belt revival meeting.
Yes, the entire package offends me as a social liberal, former football player, mature, middle-aged and accomplished adult, and as a Jewish-American. While I’ve always advocated social awareness and a sense of conviction among our professional athletes, I also expect that if one is going to spout off in public, one should be able to discuss, or be respectful of, both sides of an issue. I don’t see that attribute with Tebow or his supporters. Like all fundamentalists, their view is all or nothing, and they preach it accordingly. I’ve also advocated that our professional athletes bring some humility to the public forum when they make the transition from collegiate sports. I also don’t see that with Tebow and his supporters who seem to think starting NFL quarterback is Tebow’s divine birthright, and anyone who dare suggest a different position (e.g., running back or tight end) commits biblical blasphemy. It takes more than a lot of chutzpah to demand what your job description should be before you’ve been fully evaluated, drafted and signed by an NFL team. The NFL didn’t and never owed anything to this young man and his supporters. Team Tebow knew well in advanced the questions being raised about his ability to play quarterback. Lord knows it wasn’t and will not be the first time NFL scouts and coaches had doubts about U-of-F or SEC quarterbacks, Heisman winners or not. But Team Tebow insisted starting NFL quarterback was the Lord’s mission.
Lastly, for those who admire Tebow’s commitment to faith (and that includes me, to a limited degree), what if the quarterback’s name was Chaim Lipschitz, a rebel kid from Crown Heights who dropped out of a Yeshiva to learn about and play football at a Big East program like Rutgers? What if Rutgers had to petition to the Big East and NCAA to ensure all their games were played on Thursdays? What if Mr. Lipschitz was a bearded version of Dan Marino inside the stadium and looked like he should be working in the Diamond District outside the stadium? What if ESPN interviewed him before the draft and he started quoting from the Talmud? What if the team drafting him found out he couldn’t play for an entire month of the regular season because games conflicted with Rosh Hashanah, Yom Kippur and Sukkot?
And this brings us to Mr. Skip Bayless, ESPN’s version of Anne Coulter. Here’s a man who’s so blindly supportive of Tim Tebow that he actually told Stephen A. Smith during a First Take debate that Tebow was being “discriminated” against for being a running quarterback, just like Michael Vick and Vince Young. I was just as incredulous as Smith was when Bayless offered this theory. Vick and Young are African-American quarterbacks, and that’s why they were discriminated against, just like Donovan McNabb, Warren Moon, and Doug Williams were. These men weren’t discriminated because of their ability or inability to run; they were discriminated on the basis of their race and presumed lack of intellect. Now, I will go on the record and say that neither Michael Vick nor Vince Young have the intellect to be successful NFL quarterbacks like many other quarterbacks are and have been, but I also have that same assessment for Tim Tebow. Vick, Young and Tebow can’t hold a candle to McNabb or Moon, not to mention Steve Young, Joe Montana, or John Elway when it comes to intellect about the game as well as the ability to run and pass. The ability to play NFL quarterback is a function of talent and smarts, not the color of one’s skin.
That a veteran sportswriter like Bayless would even utter the notion that Tebow is some kind of persecution victim not only shows a complete lack of understanding about what “discrimination” even means, but demonstrates why our continuously evolving and diversifying nation continues to polarize worse and worse. Does Tebow represent some kind of “getting back America” mentality that white, fundamental Christians have been yammering about since the 2008 presidential election? Yes, I think there’s some element to that, but one only need to listen to more of Bayless’ “bloviating” to see something more troubling and hypocritical.
Surprisingly, Bayless advocates for Michael Vick and Vince Young as running quarterbacks, so Bayless isn’t necessarily using race as his lens, even though he doesn’t completely understand how to use race in the first place. But Bayless is not necessarily an advocate of Donovan McNabb, an African-American (and a proud and dignified one) quarterback who used to be a good runner. After McNabb was granted his release by the Minnesota Vikings yesterday, Bayless commented that McNabb was “out of shape” towards the end of his tenure with the Philadelphia Eagles, when he reported to the Washington Redskins last year (after the Eagles traded him), and when he reported to the Vikings for training camp this year. Bayless questioned McNabb’s conditioning and commitment to playing football after a 12-year NFL career. While some folks might agree with Bayless’ view and see nothing more to it, I’m not among them.
It’s no secret that as this NFL season has progressed, Bayless has been extremely vocal in his distain for Green Bay Packers quarterback Aaron Rodgers. Despite last season’s Super Bowl championship and this season’s 11-0 start and Rodgers statistics (127.7 QB rating, 33 TDs, 4 INTs, almost 3500 yards passing), Bayless swears by New England Patriots quarterback Tom Brady (105.5 QB rating, 28 TDs, 10 INTs, over 3600 yards passing) as the Most-Valuable Player. This is highly confusing but not impossible to decipher.
We need to begin with a basic question: what does Bayless have against Aaron Rodgers in Green Bay? Well, first we must appreciate that Rodgers’ younger brother, Jordan, plays quarterback for Vanderbilt University, which happens to be Bayless’ alma mater, located in Nashville, Tennessee. Bayless thinks the world of the younger Rodgers but routinely criticizes the elder one, who went to college at the University of California-Berkeley. Rodgers was a first-round draft pick of the Packers in 2005. He spent three seasons on the bench while the Packers were quarterbacked by Brett Favre. Remember him? One day in 2008, Ol’ Brett retired to his farm in Hattiesburg, Mississippi, and Rodgers inherited the quarterback job. Then Brett changed his mind and came out of retirement. Then the Packers traded Brett to the New York Jets, and... You know the rest of the story leading up to Brett’s most-recent retired status in 2011.
Brett Favre was one of Bayless’ favorites, a good ol’ boy from the heart of Dixie. Yeah, Brett drank, raised hell and played by the seat of his pants. And, boy, Ol’ Brett sure could run around and throw like the best of them, despite his lack of self-discipline. He was the 1990s version of Bobby Layne and Buddy Parker, two redneck quarterbacks who excited fans during the 1950s. If you watched Brett play the last three years of his career, he looked rather paunchy and unconditioned wearing a Jets uniform in 2008 and a Vikings uniform in 2009 and 2010, and it showed as each season moved along from September to December. He looked old. His behavior was erratic. He looked tired. He looked beaten up. He looked washed up. He played injured, costing his teams while he padded his Hall of Fame resume. More often than not, Brett Favre came out on the right end of the scoreboard, which is one of many reasons for his eventual enshrinement in Canton. But the Packers discarded this noble Prince of the South before Brett and his fans thought the time was right, making Aaron Rodgers an enemy of the Rebel Flag.
So now we can connect some dots: Skip Bayless gushes over Brett Favre, Michael Vick, Vince Young and Tim Tebow, and even Jordan Rodgers, but not Donovan McNabb (a Chicago native who played college football for Syracuse) or Aaron Rodgers. This may be but a limited sample of Skip Bayless, but might we be shocked to go through his publishing and social media archives and see mostly positive support for quarterbacks like Phillip Rivers, Jay Cutler, the Manning brothers, the late Steve McNair, Tony Romo and Drew Brees — quarterbacks who either grew up in the South, played college football in the South, or play for Southern-state NFL teams? Might we conversely notice mostly negative support towards quarterbacks like Steve Young (Connecticut native, graduate of BYU in Utah), Mark Sanchez (Southern California native, played at USC) or even Matt Hasselbach (Massachusetts native, graduate of Boston College)?
It’s just a thought, but perhaps Skip Bayless wears more than his support of Tim Tebow on his sleeve, and is incapable of socio-political neutrality. If Bayless was specifically an employee of some southern pep squad, perhaps his blatant bias would be both understandable and acceptable, but Bayless is a journalist, and paid to maintain the standards of neutrality for a cable network that does not act in any politically-driven capacity. If Bayless’ heart is that entrenched in the heart of Dixie, then perhaps ESPN should relocate him geographically to his own private studio where his loyalties and commitment to objectivity are. Again, ask yourself how Bayless would represent ESPN if the Denver Broncos quarterback’s name was Chaim Lipschitz.
Reminder — Don’t forget my new book is available (and on sale) in both paperback and eBook (PDF) format at Lulu.com.
Contact me for further discounts or coupon information. Buy and read it because you want something to THINK about.
Philosophy of “Packer” Pedagogy:
Vince Lombardi, critical thinking and problem-based learning
Tuesday, November 8, 2011
No Longer Penn State Proud -- Doc’s Sports Thoughts for November 8, 2011
Most folks know my doctoral degree is from Penn State University. If you didn’t, now you do. I used to be very proud of that degree. I worked long and hard for it under challenging circumstances, and was extremely proud that my PhD came from a world-class university that everyone recognized. As of a few days ago I ceased being proud — not of the degree, but from where it was earned.
Many of us know the mind-boggling news out of Happy Valley, that a sexual abuse scandal has existed on Penn State’s campus, specifically within its lauded football program, for the better part of two decades. I’m too sickened by the details to write them in a column, so I’ll leave things at this: if the allegations (and we all need to keep in mind that these are still allegations, not convictions in a Court of Law) against former Penn State defensive coordinator Jerry Sandusky are true, the moral stench from the mountains of central Pennsylvania extends from more than Sandusky, athletic director Tim Curley, and another administrator, Gary Schultz. The stench comes from legendary head coach Joe Paterno, university president Graham Spanier, assistant coach Mike McQueary, and even a couple of janitors who saw evil but didn’t speak up about it after a 2000 incident.
Let’s start from the top: Graham Spanier sold his soul to the devil to return to Penn State and become its 16th president in 1995 after a previous tenure in Happy Valley between 1973 and 1982. He had a distinguished record. He was even the founding editor of the Journal of Family Issues, ironically. I was in the final leg of my PhD work when Spanier interviewed for his current job. It didn’t take many folks long to figure out he’d do anything to get the job. Now he’s sitting in his office trying to figure out how to hang onto his job. If — and that’s the key word for the moment, given where the legal process is -- Sandusky, Curley and Schultz are convicted or cop a plea in court, Spanier’s head needs to roll, because this all took place under his watch and the buck needs to stop at the president’s desk. Spanier is no longer a spring chicken; he’s in his mid-sixties, has been an educator for nearly forty years. He’s already at the summit of his career, comfortable and possibly governing on autopilot after all these years. If Spanier has been aware of Sandusky’s alleged antics since the beginning of his presidency, his office and position is now a lot less comfortable with nowhere to hide.
Everyone knows the stellar coaching career of Joe Paterno, an icon for 46 years who put Penn State on everyone’s map. Never mind the fact that Penn State has had its share of Nobel Prize winners among the faculty; Paterno’s football program brought big-time recognition to the American masses. Cries for his graceful retirement have existed for at least a dozen years, but at approximately 85 years old, Coach Paterno continues his winning tradition. Unfortunately, his record for a clean program is now irrevocably dirtied, not by players, booster money or agents, but by one of his former assistant coaches. No matter how the legal proceedings play out, Paterno is toast and this is really the final straw for those advocating his removal. At 85 years old, he’s been through enough and served the university enough, but in some ways he’s failed at serving his university and community on a much different level. Yes, football is “God” at major universities like Penn State. I understand and appreciate the mentality because I played college football too, but for a team Penn State routinely trounces on Saturdays.
I’ve met Paterno on a few occasions during my adult life, as both a player on an opposing college team thirty years ago and as a doctoral student teaching physics courses and tutoring for the athletic department nearly twenty years ago. Each encounter was positive; he always struck me as a nice man who cared about students and academics. But football and Paterno aren’t G-d, and Paterno needs to step down at the end of the season and allow a total housecleaning of the football program and athletic department.
What about McQueary? As a graduate student assistant, meaning he was already a college graduate and legal adult, he allegedly witnessed a 2002 shower rape by Sandusky, didn’t stop it, didn’t try to interfere with it, or protect the little boy being assaulted. But he ran home to his father and reported what he saw to him and Paterno. Paterno went to Curley. We all somewhat know the rest of the story from other newspaper articles or news stories written far better than my column.
What about the janitors who saw something in 2000? What about then-Centre County District Attorney Ray Gricar, who never filed charges against Sandusky after a reported incident and investigation in 1998?
Right now no one’s talking on the record. Sandusky is under a gag order by his own attorneys. The typical Tuesday press conference Paterno has before football games was first scheduled for this afternoon but with limits as to the scope of questions and topics Paterno would address. Then the press conference is canceled without Paterno’s approval. Then reports come out that Paterno would step down immediately. Now we hear he’ll remain head coach for the foreseeable future. Given his age and the circumstances, it’s probably wise for Paterno not to meet with the press during a media feeding frenzy. But something really isn’t passing the “smell test” as everyone relevant to this story has clammed up on the Penn State campus. Even during the Watergate scandal, President Nixon’s administration issued daily public denials until the roof caved in from the mounting evidence. Paterno needs to make a public statement because this alleged abuse took place within his football kingdom. Spanier needs to make a public statement because this alleged abuse took place on his campus. Yes, the legal process may warrant a gag order among the Penn State higher-ups, but this isn’t just any scandal or criminal case. Paterno and Spanier need to come out of hiding and speak up. Neither man has the luxury of time to circle the wagons and get their stories straight. There are too many inflamed wounds across the nation and national sports scene to give Paterno and Spanier time to work with spin doctors, not after the allegations that they’ve had at least fifteen years to prepare for the court of public opinion. I want to hear what both of them have to say. I want to believe this story doesn’t stink all the way to the top of this university. I want to allow the legal process to play itself out to completion, but today I have a hard time believing anything coming out of this particular alma mater.
Aside from the sickening details of this story, what nauseates me most is how the child protection laws in Pennsylvania theoretically allow Paterno, Spanier, McQueary, Gricar, the unnamed janitors, and any other number of adults off the hook for Sandusky’s alleged criminal behavior. What did adults know and when did they know anything? Who did they report things to? Did they report things enough to as many state agencies or entities as possible? Right now we don’t know, but we do know this: according to Pennsylvania Attorney General Linda Kelly, Paterno and other adults are not necessarily people of interest or under investigation because they “met the minimal criteria” with respect to the law’s obligation for reporting child abuse. I repeat that again... met the minimal criteria.
I’m sorry, but I’ve never been a big fan of meeting minimal criteria, or being “sufficiently adequate” when it comes to anything beyond how I cook my own meals and clean my home (once you use a wheelchair and walker, some standards get a little lax). To me, this is the biggest crime of the entire criminal story. Why? Because if you can get by with meeting minimal criteria with respect to protection of children, what else can we get away with meeting minimal criteria for? Protection of the old, sick, disabled, racial or ethnic minorities, members of the GLBT community, the poor, not to mention anyone else vulnerable to the whims of our cold society?
For the time being, we all have to keep this scandal in perspective because a legal process needs to play out. However, we are working with the limited knowledge that McQueary and Paterno went through their “chain of command” and supposedly did their legal parts. Okay, maybe that’s the right way to do things at a large state university with incredible layers of bureaucracy and regulations to deal with, but we all feel in our bones that something doesn’t seem right. None of us is really in a position to be the moralist on protocol, least of all me, but one’s values need to be questioned when we hear “Met the minimal criteria... Said something to somebody... Did all I needed or could do.”
Did McQueary and Paterno do enough? Shouldn’t they have gone beyond the insulated walls of Penn State’s campus? Are they able to really live with their decisions to this very day? Can either or both of these men look straight in their mirrors and say “I did enough. I did my best. I couldn’t have done anything more”? I don’t know how either man can without blinking or turning away from the mirror, do you? In a sport where players are taught to play through the final whistle, you don’t tell anyone you met any minimal criteria or did all you needed or could do until everyone sees the final scoreboard. I’m left wondering if McQueary and Paterno walked off to the proverbial locker room long before halftime of this story.
Beyond the questions about McQueary’s and Paterno’s limited actions, we must ask why Sandusky retired at age 55 in 1999 when most Penn State football fans presumed he would be Paterno’s successor, why Sandusky was retired but still allowed to hold his Second-Mile camps on Penn State property, why Sandusky was allowed to be around young boys after being investigated for the first allegations of sexual misconduct, and why Sandusky wasn’t a pariah and unwelcomed at the campus after the 2002 incident McQueary and Paterno reported. Sandusky’s been under investigation in one form or another since 1998. Maybe Penn State wanted to wash its hands of Sandusky, but it didn’t really do a thorough job in retrospect, did it? Sandusky and his alleged problems never disappeared, leaving a lasting stain.
The more we read various news articles and the grand jury report available on the internet, the more we wonder if McQueary, Paterno, Curley, Schultz and Spanier, as well as Gricar and nameless janitors and other Penn State employees, were more worried about their own jobs and careers than these alleged abuse victims. Think about it... Just who the hell is Jerry Sandusky in the grand scheme of things? Yes, he was the man who guided Penn State’s defense to great achievement on the gridiron, but was he that powerful a person that all of the aforementioned people would fear him and his retribution if they went forward to local and state authorities? Sandusky’s an alleged, and now indicted, sexual predator, and all of these people enabled him, embraced him, protected him — Sandusky, not the kids whose lives are irrevocably damaged.
What gives? Sure, we know sexual pedophilia exists all over the world. This isn’t limited to State College or rural Pennsylvania. It goes on all over the United States, independent of geography, size of town or community, socio-economic status, race or ethnicity, or religion. The Catholic Church protected pedophile priests. Orthodox Jewish yeshivas protected pedophile rabbis. I’m sure it goes on with fundamental Christians, Muslims and Hindus too. The late tennis star and humanitarian Arthur Ashe once said “everyone needs someone to beat up on.” It shouldn’t be that way but people in power and the “haves” in our Orwellian world need powerless and “have-nots” in order to thrive. Without others to demoralize life isn’t worth living for some people, because there aren’t carcasses underneath to support their self-imposed pedestal. Pedophilia isn’t love, folks; it’s cruelty and a sick need to lord over others when nothing else justifies the pedophile’s status in his or her food chain.
It seems that McQueary, Paterno, Curley, Schultz, Spanier, Gricar and others all worried about their own bacon first, the mode of self-preservation. These allegedly abuse boys were collateral damage for the greater good of Penn State and Nittany Lion football. McQueary was just starting out his coaching career, so perhaps he didn’t want to do anything to kill his career before it ever got underway. How was he rewarded? He’s now a full-time, full-fledged and well-paid assistant coach for one of the nation’s biggest football programs. What happens if and when Penn State cleans house? How toxic will McQueary be on the job market in 2012? How many college football programs will honestly be willing to interview or hire him, much less any of Paterno’s long-time assistants? Could McQueary find employment in the NFL? I’d be reluctant to hire him, given how much outreach work the NFL does with schools and children across the United States. What about the Canadian League? Ha! Pedophiles are viewed even worse north of the border. Aside from the alleged victims, McQueary is the only named witness to these alleged acts. We could ask if McQueary had everything to gain by his limited actions and being stage one of a massive cover-up, or we could ask if McQueary had an axe to grind against Sandusky and made up the whole story. Could McQueary be part of an extensive scheme with a bunch of kids to ruin Sandusky? Why don’t we know the identities of the unnamed janitors, also alleged witnesses? Either way, McQueary seems to be someone who really wanted to have a coaching career at Penn State.
Paterno was well into his coaching legacy. Why risk it over a pedophile scandal? Spanier just took over the job of his lifetime in 1995. He sure as hell didn’t want to do anything to risk losing it. Gricar’s no longer a DA. Curley’s soon to be no longer an AD. Schultz and the rest of these folks will eventually become nameless details as time goes by. But just like Nixon’s gang at the end of Watergate, the Penn State royal circle will all eventually fall on the sword in one way or another.
But what doesn’t make sense is that no one made Sandusky simply disappear for good, leave State College, Centre County and possibly the state of Pennsylvania. He was allowed to remain. This makes no sense. As a former professor, I’ve seen university employees, especially faculty, chased from campuses for lesser reasons.
If the legal process plays out and we ultimately learn that Sandusky was completely innocent, that all these allegations were concocted as a means to push him off the coaching staff, then we have to give credit to all these people who stood by Sandusky and didn’t completely excommunicate him. But too many things would have to take place in order for such a scheme to work, and I shudder to think Mike McQueary was the mastermind behind a giant hoax for the sake of getting his own foot in the door of Paterno’s coaching staff.
If the legal process plays out and we ultimately learn that Sandusky was indeed guilty of everything, and all of these other Penn State employees coordinated a massive cover-up, not only should all heads roll and house be cleaned, we need to know exactly what Mike McQueary’s motivations were after witnessing the alleged events of 2002, why he, Paterno, Curley, Spanier and all these other adults did as little as they could to rectify the situation, and more importantly, what special hold did Jerry Sandusky have on everyone else that they allowed a pedophile to continue business as usual in their presence. Shame on them all.
Just like everyone, I’m guilty of an endless list of things I’m not proud of, perhaps even ashamed of. Today I have something else to be ashamed of, my association with Penn State.
Reminder — Don’t forget my new book is available (and on sale) in both paperback and eBook (PDF) format at Lulu.com.
Philosophy of “Packer” Pedagogy:
Vince Lombardi, critical thinking and problem-based learning
Many of us know the mind-boggling news out of Happy Valley, that a sexual abuse scandal has existed on Penn State’s campus, specifically within its lauded football program, for the better part of two decades. I’m too sickened by the details to write them in a column, so I’ll leave things at this: if the allegations (and we all need to keep in mind that these are still allegations, not convictions in a Court of Law) against former Penn State defensive coordinator Jerry Sandusky are true, the moral stench from the mountains of central Pennsylvania extends from more than Sandusky, athletic director Tim Curley, and another administrator, Gary Schultz. The stench comes from legendary head coach Joe Paterno, university president Graham Spanier, assistant coach Mike McQueary, and even a couple of janitors who saw evil but didn’t speak up about it after a 2000 incident.
Let’s start from the top: Graham Spanier sold his soul to the devil to return to Penn State and become its 16th president in 1995 after a previous tenure in Happy Valley between 1973 and 1982. He had a distinguished record. He was even the founding editor of the Journal of Family Issues, ironically. I was in the final leg of my PhD work when Spanier interviewed for his current job. It didn’t take many folks long to figure out he’d do anything to get the job. Now he’s sitting in his office trying to figure out how to hang onto his job. If — and that’s the key word for the moment, given where the legal process is -- Sandusky, Curley and Schultz are convicted or cop a plea in court, Spanier’s head needs to roll, because this all took place under his watch and the buck needs to stop at the president’s desk. Spanier is no longer a spring chicken; he’s in his mid-sixties, has been an educator for nearly forty years. He’s already at the summit of his career, comfortable and possibly governing on autopilot after all these years. If Spanier has been aware of Sandusky’s alleged antics since the beginning of his presidency, his office and position is now a lot less comfortable with nowhere to hide.
Everyone knows the stellar coaching career of Joe Paterno, an icon for 46 years who put Penn State on everyone’s map. Never mind the fact that Penn State has had its share of Nobel Prize winners among the faculty; Paterno’s football program brought big-time recognition to the American masses. Cries for his graceful retirement have existed for at least a dozen years, but at approximately 85 years old, Coach Paterno continues his winning tradition. Unfortunately, his record for a clean program is now irrevocably dirtied, not by players, booster money or agents, but by one of his former assistant coaches. No matter how the legal proceedings play out, Paterno is toast and this is really the final straw for those advocating his removal. At 85 years old, he’s been through enough and served the university enough, but in some ways he’s failed at serving his university and community on a much different level. Yes, football is “God” at major universities like Penn State. I understand and appreciate the mentality because I played college football too, but for a team Penn State routinely trounces on Saturdays.
I’ve met Paterno on a few occasions during my adult life, as both a player on an opposing college team thirty years ago and as a doctoral student teaching physics courses and tutoring for the athletic department nearly twenty years ago. Each encounter was positive; he always struck me as a nice man who cared about students and academics. But football and Paterno aren’t G-d, and Paterno needs to step down at the end of the season and allow a total housecleaning of the football program and athletic department.
What about McQueary? As a graduate student assistant, meaning he was already a college graduate and legal adult, he allegedly witnessed a 2002 shower rape by Sandusky, didn’t stop it, didn’t try to interfere with it, or protect the little boy being assaulted. But he ran home to his father and reported what he saw to him and Paterno. Paterno went to Curley. We all somewhat know the rest of the story from other newspaper articles or news stories written far better than my column.
What about the janitors who saw something in 2000? What about then-Centre County District Attorney Ray Gricar, who never filed charges against Sandusky after a reported incident and investigation in 1998?
Right now no one’s talking on the record. Sandusky is under a gag order by his own attorneys. The typical Tuesday press conference Paterno has before football games was first scheduled for this afternoon but with limits as to the scope of questions and topics Paterno would address. Then the press conference is canceled without Paterno’s approval. Then reports come out that Paterno would step down immediately. Now we hear he’ll remain head coach for the foreseeable future. Given his age and the circumstances, it’s probably wise for Paterno not to meet with the press during a media feeding frenzy. But something really isn’t passing the “smell test” as everyone relevant to this story has clammed up on the Penn State campus. Even during the Watergate scandal, President Nixon’s administration issued daily public denials until the roof caved in from the mounting evidence. Paterno needs to make a public statement because this alleged abuse took place within his football kingdom. Spanier needs to make a public statement because this alleged abuse took place on his campus. Yes, the legal process may warrant a gag order among the Penn State higher-ups, but this isn’t just any scandal or criminal case. Paterno and Spanier need to come out of hiding and speak up. Neither man has the luxury of time to circle the wagons and get their stories straight. There are too many inflamed wounds across the nation and national sports scene to give Paterno and Spanier time to work with spin doctors, not after the allegations that they’ve had at least fifteen years to prepare for the court of public opinion. I want to hear what both of them have to say. I want to believe this story doesn’t stink all the way to the top of this university. I want to allow the legal process to play itself out to completion, but today I have a hard time believing anything coming out of this particular alma mater.
Aside from the sickening details of this story, what nauseates me most is how the child protection laws in Pennsylvania theoretically allow Paterno, Spanier, McQueary, Gricar, the unnamed janitors, and any other number of adults off the hook for Sandusky’s alleged criminal behavior. What did adults know and when did they know anything? Who did they report things to? Did they report things enough to as many state agencies or entities as possible? Right now we don’t know, but we do know this: according to Pennsylvania Attorney General Linda Kelly, Paterno and other adults are not necessarily people of interest or under investigation because they “met the minimal criteria” with respect to the law’s obligation for reporting child abuse. I repeat that again... met the minimal criteria.
I’m sorry, but I’ve never been a big fan of meeting minimal criteria, or being “sufficiently adequate” when it comes to anything beyond how I cook my own meals and clean my home (once you use a wheelchair and walker, some standards get a little lax). To me, this is the biggest crime of the entire criminal story. Why? Because if you can get by with meeting minimal criteria with respect to protection of children, what else can we get away with meeting minimal criteria for? Protection of the old, sick, disabled, racial or ethnic minorities, members of the GLBT community, the poor, not to mention anyone else vulnerable to the whims of our cold society?
For the time being, we all have to keep this scandal in perspective because a legal process needs to play out. However, we are working with the limited knowledge that McQueary and Paterno went through their “chain of command” and supposedly did their legal parts. Okay, maybe that’s the right way to do things at a large state university with incredible layers of bureaucracy and regulations to deal with, but we all feel in our bones that something doesn’t seem right. None of us is really in a position to be the moralist on protocol, least of all me, but one’s values need to be questioned when we hear “Met the minimal criteria... Said something to somebody... Did all I needed or could do.”
Did McQueary and Paterno do enough? Shouldn’t they have gone beyond the insulated walls of Penn State’s campus? Are they able to really live with their decisions to this very day? Can either or both of these men look straight in their mirrors and say “I did enough. I did my best. I couldn’t have done anything more”? I don’t know how either man can without blinking or turning away from the mirror, do you? In a sport where players are taught to play through the final whistle, you don’t tell anyone you met any minimal criteria or did all you needed or could do until everyone sees the final scoreboard. I’m left wondering if McQueary and Paterno walked off to the proverbial locker room long before halftime of this story.
Beyond the questions about McQueary’s and Paterno’s limited actions, we must ask why Sandusky retired at age 55 in 1999 when most Penn State football fans presumed he would be Paterno’s successor, why Sandusky was retired but still allowed to hold his Second-Mile camps on Penn State property, why Sandusky was allowed to be around young boys after being investigated for the first allegations of sexual misconduct, and why Sandusky wasn’t a pariah and unwelcomed at the campus after the 2002 incident McQueary and Paterno reported. Sandusky’s been under investigation in one form or another since 1998. Maybe Penn State wanted to wash its hands of Sandusky, but it didn’t really do a thorough job in retrospect, did it? Sandusky and his alleged problems never disappeared, leaving a lasting stain.
The more we read various news articles and the grand jury report available on the internet, the more we wonder if McQueary, Paterno, Curley, Schultz and Spanier, as well as Gricar and nameless janitors and other Penn State employees, were more worried about their own jobs and careers than these alleged abuse victims. Think about it... Just who the hell is Jerry Sandusky in the grand scheme of things? Yes, he was the man who guided Penn State’s defense to great achievement on the gridiron, but was he that powerful a person that all of the aforementioned people would fear him and his retribution if they went forward to local and state authorities? Sandusky’s an alleged, and now indicted, sexual predator, and all of these people enabled him, embraced him, protected him — Sandusky, not the kids whose lives are irrevocably damaged.
What gives? Sure, we know sexual pedophilia exists all over the world. This isn’t limited to State College or rural Pennsylvania. It goes on all over the United States, independent of geography, size of town or community, socio-economic status, race or ethnicity, or religion. The Catholic Church protected pedophile priests. Orthodox Jewish yeshivas protected pedophile rabbis. I’m sure it goes on with fundamental Christians, Muslims and Hindus too. The late tennis star and humanitarian Arthur Ashe once said “everyone needs someone to beat up on.” It shouldn’t be that way but people in power and the “haves” in our Orwellian world need powerless and “have-nots” in order to thrive. Without others to demoralize life isn’t worth living for some people, because there aren’t carcasses underneath to support their self-imposed pedestal. Pedophilia isn’t love, folks; it’s cruelty and a sick need to lord over others when nothing else justifies the pedophile’s status in his or her food chain.
It seems that McQueary, Paterno, Curley, Schultz, Spanier, Gricar and others all worried about their own bacon first, the mode of self-preservation. These allegedly abuse boys were collateral damage for the greater good of Penn State and Nittany Lion football. McQueary was just starting out his coaching career, so perhaps he didn’t want to do anything to kill his career before it ever got underway. How was he rewarded? He’s now a full-time, full-fledged and well-paid assistant coach for one of the nation’s biggest football programs. What happens if and when Penn State cleans house? How toxic will McQueary be on the job market in 2012? How many college football programs will honestly be willing to interview or hire him, much less any of Paterno’s long-time assistants? Could McQueary find employment in the NFL? I’d be reluctant to hire him, given how much outreach work the NFL does with schools and children across the United States. What about the Canadian League? Ha! Pedophiles are viewed even worse north of the border. Aside from the alleged victims, McQueary is the only named witness to these alleged acts. We could ask if McQueary had everything to gain by his limited actions and being stage one of a massive cover-up, or we could ask if McQueary had an axe to grind against Sandusky and made up the whole story. Could McQueary be part of an extensive scheme with a bunch of kids to ruin Sandusky? Why don’t we know the identities of the unnamed janitors, also alleged witnesses? Either way, McQueary seems to be someone who really wanted to have a coaching career at Penn State.
Paterno was well into his coaching legacy. Why risk it over a pedophile scandal? Spanier just took over the job of his lifetime in 1995. He sure as hell didn’t want to do anything to risk losing it. Gricar’s no longer a DA. Curley’s soon to be no longer an AD. Schultz and the rest of these folks will eventually become nameless details as time goes by. But just like Nixon’s gang at the end of Watergate, the Penn State royal circle will all eventually fall on the sword in one way or another.
But what doesn’t make sense is that no one made Sandusky simply disappear for good, leave State College, Centre County and possibly the state of Pennsylvania. He was allowed to remain. This makes no sense. As a former professor, I’ve seen university employees, especially faculty, chased from campuses for lesser reasons.
If the legal process plays out and we ultimately learn that Sandusky was completely innocent, that all these allegations were concocted as a means to push him off the coaching staff, then we have to give credit to all these people who stood by Sandusky and didn’t completely excommunicate him. But too many things would have to take place in order for such a scheme to work, and I shudder to think Mike McQueary was the mastermind behind a giant hoax for the sake of getting his own foot in the door of Paterno’s coaching staff.
If the legal process plays out and we ultimately learn that Sandusky was indeed guilty of everything, and all of these other Penn State employees coordinated a massive cover-up, not only should all heads roll and house be cleaned, we need to know exactly what Mike McQueary’s motivations were after witnessing the alleged events of 2002, why he, Paterno, Curley, Spanier and all these other adults did as little as they could to rectify the situation, and more importantly, what special hold did Jerry Sandusky have on everyone else that they allowed a pedophile to continue business as usual in their presence. Shame on them all.
Just like everyone, I’m guilty of an endless list of things I’m not proud of, perhaps even ashamed of. Today I have something else to be ashamed of, my association with Penn State.
Reminder — Don’t forget my new book is available (and on sale) in both paperback and eBook (PDF) format at Lulu.com.
Philosophy of “Packer” Pedagogy:
Vince Lombardi, critical thinking and problem-based learning
Saturday, October 15, 2011
It’s time for Jets to shut up and play football! -- Doc’s Sports Thoughts for October 16, 2011
Remember the good old days, April 2010, to be exact? The Jets had just pulled off a steal of a trade with the Pittsburgh Steelers for wide receiver Santonio Holmes, the MVP of Super Bowl XLIII, for a fifth-round draft choice. Despite Holmes’ off-field baggage, lots of Jets fans were excited at the prospect of quarterback Mark Sanchez having a game-breaker to throw passes to. Yes, Holmes was a great addition to the Jets passing attack. Yes, we’ll fondly recall his spectacular game-breaking and game-winning plays in 2010 against the Denver Broncos, Cleveland Browns, Detroit Lions, Houston Texans, and the New England Patriots, especially that touchdown catch in Foxborough during the Jets 28-21 AFC divisional playoff win. Yes, having Holmes back this year with a new five-year contract gave us all reason for hope of bigger and better things.
Well, so far this season, the only thing bigger seems to be Holmes’ mouth, quite possibly in direct proportion to his paycheck, and the only thing better seems to be that Jets fans will have Holmes for a full 16-game season, as opposed to 12 games last year (he was suspended for the first four games of 2010 for violating the NFL conduct policy).
Here we are, entering just the sixth game of the season, and Holmes has not once, but twice, shot off his big mouth to the press, complaining about how the Jets offense is not playing up to his standards as one of the team captains. More specifically, he has called out his quarterback and the offensive line as not doing their jobs well enough to give him the opportunities he apparently deserves in order to shine as a star and playmaker. In other words, if the line blocked better, Sanchez would be passing better, and Holmes would not only have better personal statistics but more highlight appearances on SportsCenter... Oh, and the Jets wouldn’t be a mediocre 2-3 going into Monday night’s home game against the 0-4 Miami Dolphins.
Twice, Holmes has been rebuked, first by the legendary Joe Namath, and now by Pro Bowl caliber right guard Brandon Moore. Namath called out Holmes for potentially creating a schism in the locker room. Moore made it unequivocally clear that Holmes is indeed creating division and dissention within the Jets locker room, and that’s not how a team captain is supposed to operate. Namath and Moore are absolutely right in scolding Holmes. Two of the many unwritten rules of professionalism in sports are: Dirty laundry stays inside the locker room, and Don’t throw teammates under the bus when the team is struggling. Holmes is definitely guilty of both and deserving of a court-marshal as one of the Jets team captains.
I’ve read as much as everyone else and listened to as much as everyone else on this nonsense, and don’t need any more newspapers, radio shows and television shows to tell me the Jets are in a funk, and nobody in Jets Nation needed Santonio Holmes’ yammering about it. In the grand scheme of things, perhaps Holmes’ yammering will end up being an insignificant blip of white noise, but at the present time, six weeks into a season already shaped by a lockout, truncated training camp and preseason, and salary-cap restrictions, Holmes’ big mouth has added to considerable stress and aggravation within the Jets locker room. To say Holmes’ comments to the media have been extremely unhelpful for the team is the season’s biggest understatement so far.
Yes, the Jets are 2-3. Yes, the Jets are riding a three-game losing streak, going 0-3 on a road trip through Oakland, Baltimore, and New England. Yes, the Jets are struggling on both offense and defense, giving up big plays, making too many mistakes, and committing too many penalties. Yes, the offense has yet to find its rushing attack, rushing-passing balance, and consistency with its passing game. Yes, the offensive line has been banged-up and isn’t blocking up to its usual level. Yes, Mark Sanchez has been very inconsistent connecting with his receivers. Yes, playmakers like Holmes have yet to put up big statistics so far.
But we’re only entering the sixth week of the season, the Raiders, Ravens and Patriots are hardly pushovers (the Ravens and Patriots are considered by many as preseason Super Bowl favorites), three-game losing streaks aren’t necessarily impossible to overcome, and there really isn’t any crime in losing on the road. If one objectively looked at the Jets regular season schedule once the lockout ended, one really shouldn’t be shocked the Jets are only 2-3. In fact, an objective Jets fan would’ve expected 3-2 to be a reasonably decent start, given their recent three-game road trip. More importantly, only the most cockeyed of Jets fans would’ve expected Gang Green to have a 2011 record of 13-3 or better. Most experts and realists figured the Jets to be 11-5 (same as last season) or possibly 12-4, so somewhere along the season we all expected the Jets to lose three games. Well, those three losses are now on the books. Perhaps it’s better those three losses come in September and October, rather than in November and December?
Should we completely disregard those three losses and not worry about what we saw over the past three weeks? No, of course not. The Jets lost three games against AFC opponents, three teams all potentially battling the Jets for playoff spots in December, when tiebreakers could be critical. The Jets looked flat and a step behind against the Raiders, reminding us that speed is important and the Jets don’t have as much speed on their roster as desired. The Jets offense looked entirely overmatched against the Ravens (then again, so did the Steelers in the season opener, and Pittsburgh played in last year’s Super Bowl), reminding us that a healthy offensive line is paramount when going against an aggressive defense. The Jets offense struggled on first and third downs against the Patriots suspect defense, reminding us that if you can’t keep Tom Brady off the field, eventually he and his offensive mates will wear down and kill any defense. There were lots of little things not to like about the Jets three-game losing streak and how it transpired. However, there were no major things taking place to hint at a team completely incapable of being in the hunt for a playoff spot and that elusive Super Bowl berth. There are things to fix, and fixed these things will eventually be, because head coach Rex Ryan, and his entire coaching staff, have found ways to fix things en route to the previous two AFC championship games and one step short of the Super Bowl.
And how “bad” is the offense doing — i.e., how much is Mark Sanchez holding back the offense with his regressive play? Let’s get something straight: Sanchez’s stats are not much different than many other AFC quarterbacks. Sanchez has completed 97 of 173 passes, a 56 percent completion percentage. Granted, this isn’t exactly the 68 percent by Tom Brady, but it’s better than the 49.3 percent by Baltimore’s Joe Flacco and not far behind the 59.8 percent by Houston’s Matt Schaub. By the way, the Ravens are 3-1 and the Texans are 3-2, the Texans play at Baltimore this afternoon, and neither team is running away from the AFC pack so far.
After five games, Sanchez has thrown 8 touchdowns and 5 interceptions. Only Brady, Schaub, the Buffalo Bills Ryan Fitzpatrick, and Matt Hasselbeck of the Tennessee Titans have passed for more TDs. The Patriots and Bills are both 4-1, and the Titans are 3-2. Let it also be stated that Brady has already thrown 6 picks after five games, Schaub has thrown 5, as has Matt Cassel of the Kansas City Chiefs. Supposed elite AFC quarterbacks Ben Roethlisberger of the Steelers and Phillip Rivers of the San Diego Chargers have thrown seven and six interceptions, respectively, already. The Steelers are 3-2; the Chargers are 4-1. The bottom line is that Sanchez’s statistics aren’t glaringly different from many other AFC quarterbacks, quarterbacks held in higher regard and for teams considered more successful than the Jets so far. In fact, it looks like even the best of the best are having their off-moments, not too surprising for a season where everyone started out of synch after the lockout ended.
In fact, going into this weekend, 14 of 32 NFL teams are either 2-3, 2-2, or 3-2. In other words, almost half the league is within a game of .500 at the one-third mark of the season. This means at least half the league’s teams are still considered “in the hunt” for the playoffs with 10 or 11 games left to play. The Jets are among those “in the hunt” teams. However, given the annual hype since Rex Ryan became head coach, the Jets are expected to dominate, not simply be in the hunt. Well, if being in the hunt is below par, I can think of worse positions to be in after five weeks. Yes, the Jets could and perhaps should be playing better at this stage of the season, but they could be doing worse, and there are indeed a handful of teams who are playing considerably worse than the Jets. Maybe we should all count the Jets blessings instead of their omissions from the SportsCenter highlights list. It’s a shame Santonio Holmes can’t keep things in perspective, but then again, who knows how many times he has himself starting on his NFL fantasy team?
It’s bad enough inflated expectations have Jets fans flying off the handle and calling into radio stations as if the sky is falling during this recent losing streak, but to have players like Holmes sounding off rubs salt into everyone’s wounds. Holmes exacerbated a difficult situation and helps create more pressure than necessary when a bumbling team like the Dolphins come to town. The Dolphins are exactly what a struggling team needs to feel better and right the ship, but when fans and players are going off the wagon and losing perspective, the 0-4 team ends up having an artificial advantage because now the Jets run the risk of pressing harder to score 10-point touchdowns every time the offense takes the field. There’s no need to panic. Just work on correcting the mistakes, improving the physicality at the line of scrimmage, playing smarter and score your touchdowns seven points at a time. Consider yourselves lucky you get to fix what ails you against an 0-4 team rather than a 4-0 team. In other words, relax and play Jets football against a team that has no business challenging the Jets when playing to their potential.
Did Holmes say anything we don’t already know regarding what ails the Jets? No, but there was no value or benefit to him saying what he said, except to make himself absolvable of the team’s 2-3 start and struggles. Anyone who truly understands football and the team concept knows Holmes is full of baloney and chutzpah. If Holmes truly was worthy of being a team captain, if he couldn’t keep his mouth shut, he could have and should have said: “we’re all struggling on offense to play up to our potential. As a playmaker, I need to find ways to get open quicker for my quarterback to successfully pass the ball to me and place less stress on our offensive linemen.”
Holmes, a team captain and playmaker, should be talking about how he can help Sanchez, as well as the offensive line: Moore, Mangold, D’Brickashaw Ferguson, Matt Slausen and Wayne Hunter. But Holmes isn’t about helping his teammates as much as himself. After all, charity begins at home, and apparently yards-per-catch average, touchdowns, and SportsCenter highlight catches mean more to Holmes than fighting for the ball and the tough yards. Right now, no Jets receiver has the luxury of gliding downfield for four or five seconds to catch rainbow bombs from Sanchez, so everyone needs to buckle up their chin straps and dig underneath opposing coverages to find open spots where Sanchez can reach them for modest but positive gains. Homeruns will have to take a back seat to “small ball” as the offense grinds four or five yards at a time to covert series of first downs en route to the end zone. If this is what it takes this season, so be it. If it’s simply a matter of time before jabbing away leads to bigger plays, then Holmes needs to bite his tongue, as Moore advised, and be part of the jabbing attack until the offense finally breaks through.
I was among those fans a year ago who wondered if Holmes presence might blow up on Ryan and the Jets organization. Keep in mind, Holmes wore out his welcome so much in Pittsburgh that they gave him away for a fifth-round choice only two years after being a Super Bowl MVP. When times are tough and your head coach has either enough faith or naïveté to name you one of the team captains, perhaps you should have the wisdom and humility to support your teammates like someone who was traded for peanuts, not someone who won an MVP on the basis of a SportsCenter highlight catch. It’s time Holmes finally bought into the tune “When you’re a Jet, you’re a Jet all the way...” instead of constantly humming Da-da-da! Da-da-da! to himself.
As I advised Jets fans during the past week via Twitter, it’s still a long season to go, anything can happen, so try to keep the pessimism balanced a little longer. Quit griping and start encouraging your team to straighten up and play real Jets football. As for the Jets, it’s time for everyone to stop popping off to the media and figure out how to play smarter. You may not have the talent, speed, power, strength, health or depth to dominate like you expected to, but championship-caliber teams find ways to overcome challenges and struggles by using their heads better than any opponent. As I wrote in Philosophy of “Packer” pedagogy, Vince Lombardi and his teams found ways to win games when opponents had the physical advantage. There’s no reason why Rex Ryan’s Jets can’t do the same. The time has come for Gang Green to show itself and everyone else that talking a good game is one thing, thinking a good game is another.
Reminder — Don’t forget my new Book! Available in both paperback and eBook (PDF) format.
Philosophy of “Packer” Pedagogy:
Vince Lombardi, critical thinking and problem-based learning
http://www.lulu.com/spotlight/DavePushkin_PackerPedagogy
Well, so far this season, the only thing bigger seems to be Holmes’ mouth, quite possibly in direct proportion to his paycheck, and the only thing better seems to be that Jets fans will have Holmes for a full 16-game season, as opposed to 12 games last year (he was suspended for the first four games of 2010 for violating the NFL conduct policy).
Here we are, entering just the sixth game of the season, and Holmes has not once, but twice, shot off his big mouth to the press, complaining about how the Jets offense is not playing up to his standards as one of the team captains. More specifically, he has called out his quarterback and the offensive line as not doing their jobs well enough to give him the opportunities he apparently deserves in order to shine as a star and playmaker. In other words, if the line blocked better, Sanchez would be passing better, and Holmes would not only have better personal statistics but more highlight appearances on SportsCenter... Oh, and the Jets wouldn’t be a mediocre 2-3 going into Monday night’s home game against the 0-4 Miami Dolphins.
Twice, Holmes has been rebuked, first by the legendary Joe Namath, and now by Pro Bowl caliber right guard Brandon Moore. Namath called out Holmes for potentially creating a schism in the locker room. Moore made it unequivocally clear that Holmes is indeed creating division and dissention within the Jets locker room, and that’s not how a team captain is supposed to operate. Namath and Moore are absolutely right in scolding Holmes. Two of the many unwritten rules of professionalism in sports are: Dirty laundry stays inside the locker room, and Don’t throw teammates under the bus when the team is struggling. Holmes is definitely guilty of both and deserving of a court-marshal as one of the Jets team captains.
I’ve read as much as everyone else and listened to as much as everyone else on this nonsense, and don’t need any more newspapers, radio shows and television shows to tell me the Jets are in a funk, and nobody in Jets Nation needed Santonio Holmes’ yammering about it. In the grand scheme of things, perhaps Holmes’ yammering will end up being an insignificant blip of white noise, but at the present time, six weeks into a season already shaped by a lockout, truncated training camp and preseason, and salary-cap restrictions, Holmes’ big mouth has added to considerable stress and aggravation within the Jets locker room. To say Holmes’ comments to the media have been extremely unhelpful for the team is the season’s biggest understatement so far.
Yes, the Jets are 2-3. Yes, the Jets are riding a three-game losing streak, going 0-3 on a road trip through Oakland, Baltimore, and New England. Yes, the Jets are struggling on both offense and defense, giving up big plays, making too many mistakes, and committing too many penalties. Yes, the offense has yet to find its rushing attack, rushing-passing balance, and consistency with its passing game. Yes, the offensive line has been banged-up and isn’t blocking up to its usual level. Yes, Mark Sanchez has been very inconsistent connecting with his receivers. Yes, playmakers like Holmes have yet to put up big statistics so far.
But we’re only entering the sixth week of the season, the Raiders, Ravens and Patriots are hardly pushovers (the Ravens and Patriots are considered by many as preseason Super Bowl favorites), three-game losing streaks aren’t necessarily impossible to overcome, and there really isn’t any crime in losing on the road. If one objectively looked at the Jets regular season schedule once the lockout ended, one really shouldn’t be shocked the Jets are only 2-3. In fact, an objective Jets fan would’ve expected 3-2 to be a reasonably decent start, given their recent three-game road trip. More importantly, only the most cockeyed of Jets fans would’ve expected Gang Green to have a 2011 record of 13-3 or better. Most experts and realists figured the Jets to be 11-5 (same as last season) or possibly 12-4, so somewhere along the season we all expected the Jets to lose three games. Well, those three losses are now on the books. Perhaps it’s better those three losses come in September and October, rather than in November and December?
Should we completely disregard those three losses and not worry about what we saw over the past three weeks? No, of course not. The Jets lost three games against AFC opponents, three teams all potentially battling the Jets for playoff spots in December, when tiebreakers could be critical. The Jets looked flat and a step behind against the Raiders, reminding us that speed is important and the Jets don’t have as much speed on their roster as desired. The Jets offense looked entirely overmatched against the Ravens (then again, so did the Steelers in the season opener, and Pittsburgh played in last year’s Super Bowl), reminding us that a healthy offensive line is paramount when going against an aggressive defense. The Jets offense struggled on first and third downs against the Patriots suspect defense, reminding us that if you can’t keep Tom Brady off the field, eventually he and his offensive mates will wear down and kill any defense. There were lots of little things not to like about the Jets three-game losing streak and how it transpired. However, there were no major things taking place to hint at a team completely incapable of being in the hunt for a playoff spot and that elusive Super Bowl berth. There are things to fix, and fixed these things will eventually be, because head coach Rex Ryan, and his entire coaching staff, have found ways to fix things en route to the previous two AFC championship games and one step short of the Super Bowl.
And how “bad” is the offense doing — i.e., how much is Mark Sanchez holding back the offense with his regressive play? Let’s get something straight: Sanchez’s stats are not much different than many other AFC quarterbacks. Sanchez has completed 97 of 173 passes, a 56 percent completion percentage. Granted, this isn’t exactly the 68 percent by Tom Brady, but it’s better than the 49.3 percent by Baltimore’s Joe Flacco and not far behind the 59.8 percent by Houston’s Matt Schaub. By the way, the Ravens are 3-1 and the Texans are 3-2, the Texans play at Baltimore this afternoon, and neither team is running away from the AFC pack so far.
After five games, Sanchez has thrown 8 touchdowns and 5 interceptions. Only Brady, Schaub, the Buffalo Bills Ryan Fitzpatrick, and Matt Hasselbeck of the Tennessee Titans have passed for more TDs. The Patriots and Bills are both 4-1, and the Titans are 3-2. Let it also be stated that Brady has already thrown 6 picks after five games, Schaub has thrown 5, as has Matt Cassel of the Kansas City Chiefs. Supposed elite AFC quarterbacks Ben Roethlisberger of the Steelers and Phillip Rivers of the San Diego Chargers have thrown seven and six interceptions, respectively, already. The Steelers are 3-2; the Chargers are 4-1. The bottom line is that Sanchez’s statistics aren’t glaringly different from many other AFC quarterbacks, quarterbacks held in higher regard and for teams considered more successful than the Jets so far. In fact, it looks like even the best of the best are having their off-moments, not too surprising for a season where everyone started out of synch after the lockout ended.
In fact, going into this weekend, 14 of 32 NFL teams are either 2-3, 2-2, or 3-2. In other words, almost half the league is within a game of .500 at the one-third mark of the season. This means at least half the league’s teams are still considered “in the hunt” for the playoffs with 10 or 11 games left to play. The Jets are among those “in the hunt” teams. However, given the annual hype since Rex Ryan became head coach, the Jets are expected to dominate, not simply be in the hunt. Well, if being in the hunt is below par, I can think of worse positions to be in after five weeks. Yes, the Jets could and perhaps should be playing better at this stage of the season, but they could be doing worse, and there are indeed a handful of teams who are playing considerably worse than the Jets. Maybe we should all count the Jets blessings instead of their omissions from the SportsCenter highlights list. It’s a shame Santonio Holmes can’t keep things in perspective, but then again, who knows how many times he has himself starting on his NFL fantasy team?
It’s bad enough inflated expectations have Jets fans flying off the handle and calling into radio stations as if the sky is falling during this recent losing streak, but to have players like Holmes sounding off rubs salt into everyone’s wounds. Holmes exacerbated a difficult situation and helps create more pressure than necessary when a bumbling team like the Dolphins come to town. The Dolphins are exactly what a struggling team needs to feel better and right the ship, but when fans and players are going off the wagon and losing perspective, the 0-4 team ends up having an artificial advantage because now the Jets run the risk of pressing harder to score 10-point touchdowns every time the offense takes the field. There’s no need to panic. Just work on correcting the mistakes, improving the physicality at the line of scrimmage, playing smarter and score your touchdowns seven points at a time. Consider yourselves lucky you get to fix what ails you against an 0-4 team rather than a 4-0 team. In other words, relax and play Jets football against a team that has no business challenging the Jets when playing to their potential.
Did Holmes say anything we don’t already know regarding what ails the Jets? No, but there was no value or benefit to him saying what he said, except to make himself absolvable of the team’s 2-3 start and struggles. Anyone who truly understands football and the team concept knows Holmes is full of baloney and chutzpah. If Holmes truly was worthy of being a team captain, if he couldn’t keep his mouth shut, he could have and should have said: “we’re all struggling on offense to play up to our potential. As a playmaker, I need to find ways to get open quicker for my quarterback to successfully pass the ball to me and place less stress on our offensive linemen.”
Holmes, a team captain and playmaker, should be talking about how he can help Sanchez, as well as the offensive line: Moore, Mangold, D’Brickashaw Ferguson, Matt Slausen and Wayne Hunter. But Holmes isn’t about helping his teammates as much as himself. After all, charity begins at home, and apparently yards-per-catch average, touchdowns, and SportsCenter highlight catches mean more to Holmes than fighting for the ball and the tough yards. Right now, no Jets receiver has the luxury of gliding downfield for four or five seconds to catch rainbow bombs from Sanchez, so everyone needs to buckle up their chin straps and dig underneath opposing coverages to find open spots where Sanchez can reach them for modest but positive gains. Homeruns will have to take a back seat to “small ball” as the offense grinds four or five yards at a time to covert series of first downs en route to the end zone. If this is what it takes this season, so be it. If it’s simply a matter of time before jabbing away leads to bigger plays, then Holmes needs to bite his tongue, as Moore advised, and be part of the jabbing attack until the offense finally breaks through.
I was among those fans a year ago who wondered if Holmes presence might blow up on Ryan and the Jets organization. Keep in mind, Holmes wore out his welcome so much in Pittsburgh that they gave him away for a fifth-round choice only two years after being a Super Bowl MVP. When times are tough and your head coach has either enough faith or naïveté to name you one of the team captains, perhaps you should have the wisdom and humility to support your teammates like someone who was traded for peanuts, not someone who won an MVP on the basis of a SportsCenter highlight catch. It’s time Holmes finally bought into the tune “When you’re a Jet, you’re a Jet all the way...” instead of constantly humming Da-da-da! Da-da-da! to himself.
As I advised Jets fans during the past week via Twitter, it’s still a long season to go, anything can happen, so try to keep the pessimism balanced a little longer. Quit griping and start encouraging your team to straighten up and play real Jets football. As for the Jets, it’s time for everyone to stop popping off to the media and figure out how to play smarter. You may not have the talent, speed, power, strength, health or depth to dominate like you expected to, but championship-caliber teams find ways to overcome challenges and struggles by using their heads better than any opponent. As I wrote in Philosophy of “Packer” pedagogy, Vince Lombardi and his teams found ways to win games when opponents had the physical advantage. There’s no reason why Rex Ryan’s Jets can’t do the same. The time has come for Gang Green to show itself and everyone else that talking a good game is one thing, thinking a good game is another.
Reminder — Don’t forget my new Book! Available in both paperback and eBook (PDF) format.
Philosophy of “Packer” Pedagogy:
Vince Lombardi, critical thinking and problem-based learning
http://www.lulu.com/spotlight/DavePushkin_PackerPedagogy
Friday, September 16, 2011
What’s wrong with American Education? Go visit a grocery store and see for yourself! -- Doc’s Thoughts for September 16, 2011
Author’s Note: This column was originally started on September 7 and completed today. I was in the hospital last week for surgery and simply didn’t have enough time or energy to complete the column as planned. Apologies aside, I hope you’ll enjoy it.
There I was, Labor Day... A day where I could sit back and write about any number of topics on baseball (hmmm... Already wrote a column last week on the pennant races) or football (hmmm... I can do that next week. There are a few topics I’m not mentally ready to write about, particularly yesterday’s passing of former Tampa Bay Buccaneers defensive end, and teammate, Lee Roy Selmon). No... I have something more interesting and less emotionally draining to write about today... Today’s column will focus on stupidity.
(Assumed Editorial Feedback: Oh Dave, don’t you find a way to write about stupidity in almost every column?)
Well, maybe I do take advantage of opportunities and consistently try to teach one little lesson about the unwritten commandment Thou shalt not be a moron, but today is a special opportunity because it coincides with the start of a new academic year for our elementary schools, middle schools, high schools, colleges and universities, so, since it’s my column I’ll set the theme, and our theme for today is stupidity.
Well, maybe not stupidity as much as ignorance... Nope, stupidity is the appropriate theme, I’ve made up my mind, and as you read along, I’m sure you’ll appreciate how and why I came to the conclusion that stupidity is the right theme for this Labor Day column.
Before I dive into today’s story, I’d like to point out that I do take my columns seriously, even though I don’t earn any income writing them. As much as a blog column could be a vehicle for venting, I try to put as much substance as possible into my thoughts, because: (1) I’ll always be a teacher at my core, so I feel the need to teach something, or at least give readers something to think about in each column, (2) each column is potentially the core of a chapter for another book project, and (3) I don’t want to simply write a bunch of silly nonsense when my columns are distributed to approximately 5,000 people via email, Twitter, Linked-In and other social media modes. Besides, if I expect such a sizeable number of people to consistently and regularly read what I write, the least I can do is write like I’ve put significant thought behind my words.
So, here’s today’s story for our amusement and reflection...
Today I decided to take a drive to the grocery store in order to stock up on some basic food staples for the next week or two. I happen to be scheduled for a full day of medical tests on Thursday and outpatient surgery on Friday, and I know I won’t have the time or physical strength to run errands beforehand or afterwards, so today’s errand was a practical necessity, no different from how residents of the east coast recently prepared for Hurricane Irene, but with far less hysteria.
For those who know me well, I hate grocery shopping more than any domestic chore a human being must do, and this hatred for grocery shopping (make that all shopping) has continuously increased over the years since my spinal injury simply because it’s a lot of strain on my spine and legs. Even if I was a completely healthy person, I’d still consider grocery shopping tedious and far too time-consuming compared to the hours I could invest in other activities. In fact, there have been times when I’ve been completely traumatized by shopping, especially the day before a major holiday, religious or secular. Crowds are not my thing, especially crowds that grab around and over you, shoving anyone in sight all in the name of procuring that final jar of salsa during a 2-for-1 sale. In this era of coupons and manager specials, shopping is clearly a contact sport requiring helmets and other protective padding when large numbers of maniacs race up and down store isles with shopping carts and then behave similarly with their automobiles in the parking lot. Not a day goes by that I don’t pine for the days when I was young and healthy and could do my grocery shopping at 2:00am when 24-hour stores were nearly empty of people to interfere with me as I tackled this chore with quiet efficiency.
However, this column has little to do with the physical or even mental toll grocery shopping takes out of me, because those consequences will always be a part of my life no matter what day of the week, month or year I’m in a store. This column actually has to do with the aftermath of shopping.
What’s the aftermath, you ask? Ah... This takes place after you’ve completed filling your shopping cart, found a cashier lane moving at a “faster than molasses” pace, load your groceries onto the conveyer belt, hand over your frequent shopper savings card and coupons to the cashier, bag your own groceries (since another employee is rarely available for that duty and your cashier is really just the cashier, analogous to the “I don’t do windows” mentality), and pay your bill. The aftermath is when (or possibly if) you move aside with your shopping cart and inspect your receipt prior to leaving the store. I happen to be someone who scans over my receipt immediately after I leave the cashier lane, simply because I know errors happen. If I’m quick enough I can catch the error while the cashier is scanning the items and have the cashier back up and double-check a price, but today wasn’t such a day.
Anyway, while scanning today’s receipt I noticed an error at the very top; it was the only error. I needed bread (among a few other items on sale at this particular grocery store, Stop and Shop). Hey, sometimes toast or a peanut butter and jelly sandwich is all I’m in the mood to eat, so why not be prepared in case that’s all I feel like eating after surgery? It just so happens that Arnold-brand breads were on sale -- buy one and get one free of equal or lesser value.
I happen to be a very picky person when it comes to bread. I like bread with oomph, bread with substance, fiber — give me a good chewy rye bread or something with whole wheat or multigrain. You’ll never satisfy me with plain ol’ white bread, and the same goes for rolls, pita breads or wraps. I love my carbohydrates as much as anyone else, but at least give me enjoyable healthy carbohydrates. Oh, and if the bread has seeds I’m in heaven, even if the seeds get stuck in my partials. Seeds simply reinforce the oomph in the bread’s taste.
I luckily found two different loaves of Arnold breads that met my criteria, so I bought one loaf called “healthy grain whole wheat” and one loaf of “whole wheat 12-grain”. Each loaf costs $4.49, so we’re not talking cheap bread here. For $4.49, I could drive over to Whole Foods and buy a loaf of bread to die for, but I’m neither the richest person on the planet nor was I up to driving an extra 20 minutes to Whole Foods, so two loaves of healthy Arnold bread at Stop and Shop for the same price would have to do, because you can’t just drive an extra 20 minutes to Whole Foods for one loaf of bread. Shopping at Whole Foods is like those Lays Potato Chips commercials, where you can’t stop at one. If I’m going to Whole Foods, I have a significant shopping list written down to buy a bunch of food I love to eat but wish I had the budget for.
So, there I was, in Stop and Shop, receipt in hand, noticing an error. For some reason, the cash register’s computer (You have to blame it on the computer, because cashiers are simply humans scanning items with barcodes for a computer to read and provide a corresponding price. Cashiers really don’t think about what they’re scanning.) charged me for two loaves; it didn’t give me one for free. Hey, these errors happen, probably more often than we think, so I wobbled over to customer service with my shopping cart (no, I don’t really walk with my cane anymore; I wobble), showed the young lady at the counter my receipt, the Stop and Shop circular with the advertised sale for Arnold-brand breads, and the two loaves of Arnold-brand bread I bought, and explained that I shouldn’t be charged for both loaves. When you’re a reasonably logical adult, you figure this is more than sufficient information to provide someone at the customer service counter.
The problem is that the person on the other side of the customer service counter may not be as logical as you or me, and the young lady (let’s call her “Juliette”) working the customer service counter at my local Stop and Shop clearly had some logical limitations. The first thing Juliette did was randomly flip through all the pages of the circular — the very circular I handed her with the Arnold-brand bread sale ad front and center — and say, “are we even having a bread sale? I don’t see anything here.” I had to instruct Juliette to fold up the circular exactly how it was handed to her. Finally Juliette saw the ad. Juliette then carefully stared at the ad, looked up at me, and said, “you bought the wrong bread. The ad is only for 24-ounce breads.”
I now share with you the size information on each package of bread: “1 LB, 8 oz (680 g).”
I told Juliette these were 24-ounce breads (please forgive my butchered grammar... I do mean “24-ounce packages of bread”), and this is when things went downhill for Juliette...
“No-uh, you bought 8-ounce breads. It says right there.”
The package says one-pound and 8 ounces. That’s 24 ounces.
“No-uh, 1 pound is 8 ounces.”
Did you just say 1 pound is 8 ounces? How many ounces are in one pound?
“Eight. The bread says so.”
There are 16 ounces in one pound. 16 plus 8 equals 24 ounces.
“I don’t need your math lesson and attitude to know I’m right. That’s a 1-pound bread that’s 8 ounces.”
As I was just about to ask to speak to the store manager Juliette inexplicably took the two packages of Arnold bread and scanned them into her register. Sure enough, both packages registered as “Arnold Bread 24oz, $4.49”, and just like that, she opened up her cash drawer and counted out the cash owed back to me... $4.44... Yes, $4.44... Four single-dollar bills, one quarter, one dime, one nickel, and four pennies. Apparently the combination of quarters, dimes and nickels was too much to process for Juliette. This required the manager’s attention, which is another story for another column if I dare revisiting the topic.
Some of you might be wondering, what’s the big deal? You eventually got your correct refund. Yes, perhaps I eventually did, but the educator in me found the whole experience quite disturbing. Here’s a young lady, probably somewhere in the neighborhood of twenty years old. Perhaps she’s a recent high school graduate. Perhaps she’s a local college student. Perhaps she doesn’t attend school at all and is a full-time employee of Stop and Shop. But here’s a young adult who cannot figure out that “1 LB, 8 oz” is equivalent to 24 ounces, because she doesn’t know how to read a package of bread, because she doesn’t understand basic units of measurement we expect fifth graders to comprehend for the purpose of high-stakes standardized testing. I’m wiling to bet she still doesn’t believe “1 LB, 8 oz” is equivalent to 24 ounces, but she blindly trusts what the cash register tells her when she scans the package’s UPC bar code. I can only imagine how much longer I would’ve been standing at the customer service counter if her register didn’t identify the bread package weights. One would think that since each package cost $4.49 on my receipt and the circular ad explicitly stated that the price of one package without your shopping discount card was $4.49 this would be sufficient information for Juliette, but it wasn’t. Worst of all, Juliette “didn’t need math” to know she was right, even though she was indeed wrong.
This, to me, was scarier than Juliette’s ignorance of basic measurement units. As I’ve written for many years in academic journals and book chapters, adults generally have four amorphous stages of cognitive development, according to the research and theory of former Harvard psychologist William G. Perry: dualism, multiplicity, skepticism and relativism. As we encounter more experience in life, within and outside academic settings, we’re supposed to evolve towards more open-minded thinking. As researchers of the 1980s and 1990s have shown, the overwhelming majority of college graduates are essentially as narrow-minded and myopically-thinking as they were when first coming to college. What this means is that if you’re an ignorant, closed-minded blockhead at 17 or 18 years old, chances are you’re going to be the same intellectually-stunted person at 22 or 23 years old, if not older, no matter who you are, what you’ve earned a degree in, how many academic degrees you’ve earned, or where you’ve earned those degrees from. I interpret that to mean bigots and racists will likely remain bigots and racists because it takes a LOT of years to overcome your upbringing and foundation, and the same can be said for many of the negative attributes associated with a broad spectrum of American society: laziness, ignorance, functional stupidity, vanity, lack of empathy for your fellow person, etc. This is supposedly why we’re supposed to care so much about our educational system, so we can “slap to stupid” out of America’s youth before it becomes too entrenched, no matter who a child is or where that child lives. As we well see in adult society, American education hasn’t managed to land a finger, much less slap stupidity out of kids’ heads, for generations. All we need to do is open a newspaper or watch any number of television shows to see adult society has more than its share of stupidity.
Are we all capable of stupidity? Of COURSE we are! This includes you, me and everyone else who reads or doesn’t read my columns. We all do stupid (or “dumb” for those with a personal stigma about the word “stupid”) things from time to time, but we’re capable of recognizing our actions or words and rectifying the consequences as best as we can. Those stupid things we do are part of the learning experience, whether we’re organizing a monthly budget, cooking a particular meal for the first time, fixing a car, planning a party, performing a chemical experiment, solving a word problem, or quarterbacking a football game (see Dallas Cowboys and Tony Romo). The goal is to recognize, diagnose and correct our mistakes so we can avoid repeating them, or at least minimizing the times of repetition (see Dallas Cowboys and Tony Romo).
There are, however, people who don’t operate the same way we try to, because they simply can’t recognize the possibility of being fallible, and you don’t need to be in a position of power to belong in this category (see former President George W. Bush and vice-president Dick Cheney). Many years ago, 1998 to be exact, I started writing about a phenomenon I coined “cognitive capitulation.” For those new to this term, I viewed cognitive capitulators as Perry’s theory in reverse, where people could actually become more narrow-minded and less-capable of reasoning beyond one’s reference point. Back then I used to get regularly attacked by snarky graduate students who would say, “so, you want me to get outside my box and simply surrender to your way of thinking instead? I’ll show you, and remain at peace with a view I accept without outside challenge.” If you’ve read the entire homogenized quote you see how these graduate students validated my theory. I never asked anyone to “buy” what I’m selling (well, aside from the books I’ve written...); I ask people to be open-minded enough to listen to what I have to say, just like I’ve had to spend thirty years listening politely to what THEY have to say. Whether we agree with each other is irrelevant; the point is to be cognizant and respectful of our views. When we can’t do that, we become pawns of a mob mentality, defending a dominant paradigm to the proverbial death all in the name of preventing the other side from being heard.
If I told you the citizens of 1930s Germany and Italy were cognitive capitulators to Hitler and Mussolini, you’d likely see merit in that thought. If I told you members of today’s Tea Party are cognitive capitulators to people like Glenn Beck and Sarah Palin, you might feel less comfortable with the thought but you might still give it a bit of merit. If I told you that educators of the past 30-40 years are cognitive capitulators to whatever is the new mode of political expedience by people who’ve never been in a classroom, your response might depend on how supportive you are of teacher unions, or your biases about schools and American society. If I told you that today’s chemistry professors are cognitive capitulators to yesterday’s chemistry professors, you might take great offense, because a chemistry professor is supposedly someone of high intellectual integrity and independence. Really? Ever heard of tenure committees?
So what’s your response if I tell you that Juliette’s a cognitive capitulator? Do you agree with me, possibly because a young lady who can’t decipher pounds and ounces was absolutely sure she was right, I was wrong, and math was irrelevant to the conflict resolution? Or, do you disagree with me, possibly because Juliette doesn’t possess enough knowledge to think in the first place?
Where do we draw the line at debating the place of thinking in society? Does thinking only apply to certain age levels and settings in society, or should thinking be a universal concern? Is insistence of “being right” or having “the right way” of doing things only relevant to mature adults and highly-educated members of society, or possessors of supreme power? I can go on and on with this debate, but the bottom line is when do individuals come to terms with the possibility they just might be wrong on something and it’s time to shut up and listen to someone perhaps more knowledgeable, regardless of age, academic credentials, race, ethnicity, gender, or power status in society? For more than thirty years I’ve routinely wondered when exactly my ideas have merit, or more precisely: when do I finally earn the respect of any human being for the simple courtesy of allowing me to calmly demonstrate that I know what the hell I’m talking about, be it about chemistry, physics, science education, football, or buying a lousy loaf of bread?
As embarrassed as I am to say it, I had a momentary urge to “slap the stupid” out of Juliette and tell her in front of anyone and everyone at Stop and Shop: You stupid kid! Is there any little warning light in your head telling you to shut up and listen to somebody more than twice your age, who actually grew up in an era BEFORE the metric system, much less computerized cash registers?! I don’t know about you, but I take great offense having to deal with people less knowledgeable than me who are UNWILLING to defer to my level of knowledge, and that’s pretty sad considering we’re talking about a trivial 24-ounce package of bread. This is hardly deciphering the New England Patriots no-huddle offense or quantum mechanics.
This is supposed to be America’s future, folks — the next generation of citizens for a rapidly changing information age, or what former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney calls a “Smart Phone Society.” If Juliette is an example of Romney’s “Smart Phone Society”, I hope Juliette’s smart phone can do the mother load of Juliette’s thinking, because I’m skeptical that she or many of her peers can think independently of automated machines. If you think I’m getting ahead of myself, keep in mind that young people like Juliette will be the continuous faces shown during the next fourteen months leading up to the 2012 presidential election as our economy remains mired in double-digit unemployment rates for most segments of America. Imagine the possible (I’m too cynical about our government and the US Congress to say words like “eventual”) passing of a Jobs Bill and employers pointing to people like Juliette as a primary reason why unemployment still cannot be reduced, claiming “you can’t hire dummies who can’t work with the most basic of knowledge.”
Now, people like Juliette are hardly unique. We’ve all encountered our share of cashiers and store clerks who can’t count change or perform the most basic of math operations without profound difficulty, and I probably wouldn’t even dwell on it so much if I hadn’t recently seen an HBO special showing “The best of ‘Hard Knocks’”, a compilation of ten years of candid camera moments from NFL training camps. If you haven’t seen this “Hard Knocks” retrospective, there’s one scene from the New York Jets training camp last summer where one assistant coach offers another a question (I’m paraphrasing it) from the Jeff Foxworthy show “Are you smarter than a fifth grader?” -- [A child] is holding two yard sticks and a 12-inch ruler. How many feet does that equal?
Needless to say, the second Jets assistant coach could not correctly answer the question, that the child is holding seven feet of measuring sticks. Why? Because he neither understood how many feet were in a yard nor how many inches were in a foot, and football is supposedly a game of inches, feet and yards! This is considered entertainment by HBO. I consider it embarrassing that my favorite NFL team still employs an assistant coach who can’t do fifth grade math.
We can test children and young adults until the cows come home in our schools and colleges and the simple truth is that those tests will never tell us whether children or young adults genuinely learned anything or understand what educational administrators and political leaders expect these citizens to know. Chances are this Jets assistant coach scored sufficiently enough on standardized tests to get through our educational systems and find employment in the NFL. Chances are Juliette scored just as sufficiently on whatever tests she had to take during her formal education and now she works for a moderately large grocery chain like Stop and Shop. Yet neither comprehend fundamental math knowledge our nation arbitrarily considers a benchmark for being a literate citizen, and that’s rather disturbing.
So what’s the take-home lesson or punch-line to this story? In a nation still muddling through a major recession, price inflation, stagnant wages, and double-digit unemployment for people lacking at least a bachelors degree, we have politicians and political pundits all screaming about job creation, but where’s the guarantee that all these new jobs can be filled by knowledgeable and capable people? If a better-paying opportunity becomes available for people like Juliette, will they really be qualified for these opportunities? If the New York Jets suddenly fire this one assistant coach and he needs to find new employment outside of football, will there be enough jobs he’s qualified for, or will he be limited by his inability to comprehend elementary school-level math? Worse, how do we know that one day we won’t turn on the six-o’clock news one evening and hear that Juliette didn’t poison her child because she didn’t know how to properly measure the correct dosage of medicine prescribed by a pediatrician? Don’t call me an alarmist, because we’ve all heard of at least one story over the past decade or two where parents improperly administered medication to a child because they either couldn’t read the directions on the package or measure out the medicine.
Everyone makes mistakes, just as everyone is capable of having a brain freeze. Even I’ve made calculation mistakes over the years, and the mistakes have become more frequent as I’ve gotten older. But I take my mistakes to heart; I take my mistakes seriously. That’s because I take knowledge seriously. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for many citizens of Governor Romney’s “Smart Phone Society.” How many times have we heard young people (or not so young people) say there’s no need to remember certain things, because they can look it up on a computer?
What if a computer’s unavailable, like many were during Hurricane Irene, because tens of thousands of citizens were without electricity? What do you do then? Stop taking or administering medication on account of darkness? Declare a moratorium on measuring? That may be acceptable when it comes to portion control of your favorite comfort food during a blackout, but not when it comes to medication or something of equal importance.
I know... It was just a loaf of bread, but the loaf of bread is merely an example of an underlying problem with our educational system, especially when our educational system keeps emphasizing literacy and standardized testing of the basics, including mathematics. The underlying problem, folks, is that our educational system continues to fail at inspiring educators, administrators and learners to give a damn about knowledge in general. If it ain’t on the state or national test, it don’t matter. I actually wrote about this academic philosophy expressed by a veteran high school social studies teacher of the New York City public school system in my 2001 book Teacher training: A reference handbook. If there’s not high-stakes test or grade attached to information it’s simply white noise, as disposable a commodity as the six-pack of paper towels we all likely have on our typical grocery shopping lists. We teach knowledge and we test knowledge, but we really don’t care much about knowledge, simply because we don’t fully understand what knowledge is in the first place.
In my new book, Philosophy of “Packer” pedagogy I present a vision of what a critically-thinking and problem-solving literate society can be in terms of Vince Lombardi’s four core principals of teaching and learning. Lombardi’s fourth principal was “winning isn’t a sometimes thing, it’s an all the time thing.” I upgraded principal this to state: thinking and the effort to learn is (sic: are) not a sometimes thing, it’s an all the time thing. In other words, using your brain shouldn’t be an occasional luxury; it should be a daily endeavor. But we don’t have a dominant culture or society that advocates this principal beyond artificial academic assessment? How many times have we heard parents encourage or demand their children to “get good grades” as the daily objective of school. Just once, couldn’t parents encourage or demand their children demonstrate evidence of thinking, or even offer the advice don’t do anything stupid today?
As a parting thought, many of us have heard the saying “don’t argue with an idiot; no one will recognize the difference.” There’s considerable merit to that saying. Unfortunately, as you and I go through our daily lives, the sad truth is that the idiots in society tend to own the megaphones and airwaves, and we’re inundated with their oppressive droning. Ask yourself when’s the last time you were able to listen to a calm voice of reason that didn’t exist solely inside your head? Maybe it’s time we all got a little pissed off, mouthed off and slapped the stupid out of some folks. Who knows? We’ve may stun these nitwits into the silence we crave.
Reminder — Don’t forget my new Book! Don’t buy it because I’m “right” -- Buy it because I have something worthwhile to say and think about.
Philosophy of “Packer” Pedagogy:
Vince Lombardi, critical thinking and problem-based learning
http://www.lulu.com/spotlight/DavePushkin_PackerPedagogy
There I was, Labor Day... A day where I could sit back and write about any number of topics on baseball (hmmm... Already wrote a column last week on the pennant races) or football (hmmm... I can do that next week. There are a few topics I’m not mentally ready to write about, particularly yesterday’s passing of former Tampa Bay Buccaneers defensive end, and teammate, Lee Roy Selmon). No... I have something more interesting and less emotionally draining to write about today... Today’s column will focus on stupidity.
(Assumed Editorial Feedback: Oh Dave, don’t you find a way to write about stupidity in almost every column?)
Well, maybe I do take advantage of opportunities and consistently try to teach one little lesson about the unwritten commandment Thou shalt not be a moron, but today is a special opportunity because it coincides with the start of a new academic year for our elementary schools, middle schools, high schools, colleges and universities, so, since it’s my column I’ll set the theme, and our theme for today is stupidity.
Well, maybe not stupidity as much as ignorance... Nope, stupidity is the appropriate theme, I’ve made up my mind, and as you read along, I’m sure you’ll appreciate how and why I came to the conclusion that stupidity is the right theme for this Labor Day column.
Before I dive into today’s story, I’d like to point out that I do take my columns seriously, even though I don’t earn any income writing them. As much as a blog column could be a vehicle for venting, I try to put as much substance as possible into my thoughts, because: (1) I’ll always be a teacher at my core, so I feel the need to teach something, or at least give readers something to think about in each column, (2) each column is potentially the core of a chapter for another book project, and (3) I don’t want to simply write a bunch of silly nonsense when my columns are distributed to approximately 5,000 people via email, Twitter, Linked-In and other social media modes. Besides, if I expect such a sizeable number of people to consistently and regularly read what I write, the least I can do is write like I’ve put significant thought behind my words.
So, here’s today’s story for our amusement and reflection...
Today I decided to take a drive to the grocery store in order to stock up on some basic food staples for the next week or two. I happen to be scheduled for a full day of medical tests on Thursday and outpatient surgery on Friday, and I know I won’t have the time or physical strength to run errands beforehand or afterwards, so today’s errand was a practical necessity, no different from how residents of the east coast recently prepared for Hurricane Irene, but with far less hysteria.
For those who know me well, I hate grocery shopping more than any domestic chore a human being must do, and this hatred for grocery shopping (make that all shopping) has continuously increased over the years since my spinal injury simply because it’s a lot of strain on my spine and legs. Even if I was a completely healthy person, I’d still consider grocery shopping tedious and far too time-consuming compared to the hours I could invest in other activities. In fact, there have been times when I’ve been completely traumatized by shopping, especially the day before a major holiday, religious or secular. Crowds are not my thing, especially crowds that grab around and over you, shoving anyone in sight all in the name of procuring that final jar of salsa during a 2-for-1 sale. In this era of coupons and manager specials, shopping is clearly a contact sport requiring helmets and other protective padding when large numbers of maniacs race up and down store isles with shopping carts and then behave similarly with their automobiles in the parking lot. Not a day goes by that I don’t pine for the days when I was young and healthy and could do my grocery shopping at 2:00am when 24-hour stores were nearly empty of people to interfere with me as I tackled this chore with quiet efficiency.
However, this column has little to do with the physical or even mental toll grocery shopping takes out of me, because those consequences will always be a part of my life no matter what day of the week, month or year I’m in a store. This column actually has to do with the aftermath of shopping.
What’s the aftermath, you ask? Ah... This takes place after you’ve completed filling your shopping cart, found a cashier lane moving at a “faster than molasses” pace, load your groceries onto the conveyer belt, hand over your frequent shopper savings card and coupons to the cashier, bag your own groceries (since another employee is rarely available for that duty and your cashier is really just the cashier, analogous to the “I don’t do windows” mentality), and pay your bill. The aftermath is when (or possibly if) you move aside with your shopping cart and inspect your receipt prior to leaving the store. I happen to be someone who scans over my receipt immediately after I leave the cashier lane, simply because I know errors happen. If I’m quick enough I can catch the error while the cashier is scanning the items and have the cashier back up and double-check a price, but today wasn’t such a day.
Anyway, while scanning today’s receipt I noticed an error at the very top; it was the only error. I needed bread (among a few other items on sale at this particular grocery store, Stop and Shop). Hey, sometimes toast or a peanut butter and jelly sandwich is all I’m in the mood to eat, so why not be prepared in case that’s all I feel like eating after surgery? It just so happens that Arnold-brand breads were on sale -- buy one and get one free of equal or lesser value.
I happen to be a very picky person when it comes to bread. I like bread with oomph, bread with substance, fiber — give me a good chewy rye bread or something with whole wheat or multigrain. You’ll never satisfy me with plain ol’ white bread, and the same goes for rolls, pita breads or wraps. I love my carbohydrates as much as anyone else, but at least give me enjoyable healthy carbohydrates. Oh, and if the bread has seeds I’m in heaven, even if the seeds get stuck in my partials. Seeds simply reinforce the oomph in the bread’s taste.
I luckily found two different loaves of Arnold breads that met my criteria, so I bought one loaf called “healthy grain whole wheat” and one loaf of “whole wheat 12-grain”. Each loaf costs $4.49, so we’re not talking cheap bread here. For $4.49, I could drive over to Whole Foods and buy a loaf of bread to die for, but I’m neither the richest person on the planet nor was I up to driving an extra 20 minutes to Whole Foods, so two loaves of healthy Arnold bread at Stop and Shop for the same price would have to do, because you can’t just drive an extra 20 minutes to Whole Foods for one loaf of bread. Shopping at Whole Foods is like those Lays Potato Chips commercials, where you can’t stop at one. If I’m going to Whole Foods, I have a significant shopping list written down to buy a bunch of food I love to eat but wish I had the budget for.
So, there I was, in Stop and Shop, receipt in hand, noticing an error. For some reason, the cash register’s computer (You have to blame it on the computer, because cashiers are simply humans scanning items with barcodes for a computer to read and provide a corresponding price. Cashiers really don’t think about what they’re scanning.) charged me for two loaves; it didn’t give me one for free. Hey, these errors happen, probably more often than we think, so I wobbled over to customer service with my shopping cart (no, I don’t really walk with my cane anymore; I wobble), showed the young lady at the counter my receipt, the Stop and Shop circular with the advertised sale for Arnold-brand breads, and the two loaves of Arnold-brand bread I bought, and explained that I shouldn’t be charged for both loaves. When you’re a reasonably logical adult, you figure this is more than sufficient information to provide someone at the customer service counter.
The problem is that the person on the other side of the customer service counter may not be as logical as you or me, and the young lady (let’s call her “Juliette”) working the customer service counter at my local Stop and Shop clearly had some logical limitations. The first thing Juliette did was randomly flip through all the pages of the circular — the very circular I handed her with the Arnold-brand bread sale ad front and center — and say, “are we even having a bread sale? I don’t see anything here.” I had to instruct Juliette to fold up the circular exactly how it was handed to her. Finally Juliette saw the ad. Juliette then carefully stared at the ad, looked up at me, and said, “you bought the wrong bread. The ad is only for 24-ounce breads.”
I now share with you the size information on each package of bread: “1 LB, 8 oz (680 g).”
I told Juliette these were 24-ounce breads (please forgive my butchered grammar... I do mean “24-ounce packages of bread”), and this is when things went downhill for Juliette...
“No-uh, you bought 8-ounce breads. It says right there.”
The package says one-pound and 8 ounces. That’s 24 ounces.
“No-uh, 1 pound is 8 ounces.”
Did you just say 1 pound is 8 ounces? How many ounces are in one pound?
“Eight. The bread says so.”
There are 16 ounces in one pound. 16 plus 8 equals 24 ounces.
“I don’t need your math lesson and attitude to know I’m right. That’s a 1-pound bread that’s 8 ounces.”
As I was just about to ask to speak to the store manager Juliette inexplicably took the two packages of Arnold bread and scanned them into her register. Sure enough, both packages registered as “Arnold Bread 24oz, $4.49”, and just like that, she opened up her cash drawer and counted out the cash owed back to me... $4.44... Yes, $4.44... Four single-dollar bills, one quarter, one dime, one nickel, and four pennies. Apparently the combination of quarters, dimes and nickels was too much to process for Juliette. This required the manager’s attention, which is another story for another column if I dare revisiting the topic.
Some of you might be wondering, what’s the big deal? You eventually got your correct refund. Yes, perhaps I eventually did, but the educator in me found the whole experience quite disturbing. Here’s a young lady, probably somewhere in the neighborhood of twenty years old. Perhaps she’s a recent high school graduate. Perhaps she’s a local college student. Perhaps she doesn’t attend school at all and is a full-time employee of Stop and Shop. But here’s a young adult who cannot figure out that “1 LB, 8 oz” is equivalent to 24 ounces, because she doesn’t know how to read a package of bread, because she doesn’t understand basic units of measurement we expect fifth graders to comprehend for the purpose of high-stakes standardized testing. I’m wiling to bet she still doesn’t believe “1 LB, 8 oz” is equivalent to 24 ounces, but she blindly trusts what the cash register tells her when she scans the package’s UPC bar code. I can only imagine how much longer I would’ve been standing at the customer service counter if her register didn’t identify the bread package weights. One would think that since each package cost $4.49 on my receipt and the circular ad explicitly stated that the price of one package without your shopping discount card was $4.49 this would be sufficient information for Juliette, but it wasn’t. Worst of all, Juliette “didn’t need math” to know she was right, even though she was indeed wrong.
This, to me, was scarier than Juliette’s ignorance of basic measurement units. As I’ve written for many years in academic journals and book chapters, adults generally have four amorphous stages of cognitive development, according to the research and theory of former Harvard psychologist William G. Perry: dualism, multiplicity, skepticism and relativism. As we encounter more experience in life, within and outside academic settings, we’re supposed to evolve towards more open-minded thinking. As researchers of the 1980s and 1990s have shown, the overwhelming majority of college graduates are essentially as narrow-minded and myopically-thinking as they were when first coming to college. What this means is that if you’re an ignorant, closed-minded blockhead at 17 or 18 years old, chances are you’re going to be the same intellectually-stunted person at 22 or 23 years old, if not older, no matter who you are, what you’ve earned a degree in, how many academic degrees you’ve earned, or where you’ve earned those degrees from. I interpret that to mean bigots and racists will likely remain bigots and racists because it takes a LOT of years to overcome your upbringing and foundation, and the same can be said for many of the negative attributes associated with a broad spectrum of American society: laziness, ignorance, functional stupidity, vanity, lack of empathy for your fellow person, etc. This is supposedly why we’re supposed to care so much about our educational system, so we can “slap to stupid” out of America’s youth before it becomes too entrenched, no matter who a child is or where that child lives. As we well see in adult society, American education hasn’t managed to land a finger, much less slap stupidity out of kids’ heads, for generations. All we need to do is open a newspaper or watch any number of television shows to see adult society has more than its share of stupidity.
Are we all capable of stupidity? Of COURSE we are! This includes you, me and everyone else who reads or doesn’t read my columns. We all do stupid (or “dumb” for those with a personal stigma about the word “stupid”) things from time to time, but we’re capable of recognizing our actions or words and rectifying the consequences as best as we can. Those stupid things we do are part of the learning experience, whether we’re organizing a monthly budget, cooking a particular meal for the first time, fixing a car, planning a party, performing a chemical experiment, solving a word problem, or quarterbacking a football game (see Dallas Cowboys and Tony Romo). The goal is to recognize, diagnose and correct our mistakes so we can avoid repeating them, or at least minimizing the times of repetition (see Dallas Cowboys and Tony Romo).
There are, however, people who don’t operate the same way we try to, because they simply can’t recognize the possibility of being fallible, and you don’t need to be in a position of power to belong in this category (see former President George W. Bush and vice-president Dick Cheney). Many years ago, 1998 to be exact, I started writing about a phenomenon I coined “cognitive capitulation.” For those new to this term, I viewed cognitive capitulators as Perry’s theory in reverse, where people could actually become more narrow-minded and less-capable of reasoning beyond one’s reference point. Back then I used to get regularly attacked by snarky graduate students who would say, “so, you want me to get outside my box and simply surrender to your way of thinking instead? I’ll show you, and remain at peace with a view I accept without outside challenge.” If you’ve read the entire homogenized quote you see how these graduate students validated my theory. I never asked anyone to “buy” what I’m selling (well, aside from the books I’ve written...); I ask people to be open-minded enough to listen to what I have to say, just like I’ve had to spend thirty years listening politely to what THEY have to say. Whether we agree with each other is irrelevant; the point is to be cognizant and respectful of our views. When we can’t do that, we become pawns of a mob mentality, defending a dominant paradigm to the proverbial death all in the name of preventing the other side from being heard.
If I told you the citizens of 1930s Germany and Italy were cognitive capitulators to Hitler and Mussolini, you’d likely see merit in that thought. If I told you members of today’s Tea Party are cognitive capitulators to people like Glenn Beck and Sarah Palin, you might feel less comfortable with the thought but you might still give it a bit of merit. If I told you that educators of the past 30-40 years are cognitive capitulators to whatever is the new mode of political expedience by people who’ve never been in a classroom, your response might depend on how supportive you are of teacher unions, or your biases about schools and American society. If I told you that today’s chemistry professors are cognitive capitulators to yesterday’s chemistry professors, you might take great offense, because a chemistry professor is supposedly someone of high intellectual integrity and independence. Really? Ever heard of tenure committees?
So what’s your response if I tell you that Juliette’s a cognitive capitulator? Do you agree with me, possibly because a young lady who can’t decipher pounds and ounces was absolutely sure she was right, I was wrong, and math was irrelevant to the conflict resolution? Or, do you disagree with me, possibly because Juliette doesn’t possess enough knowledge to think in the first place?
Where do we draw the line at debating the place of thinking in society? Does thinking only apply to certain age levels and settings in society, or should thinking be a universal concern? Is insistence of “being right” or having “the right way” of doing things only relevant to mature adults and highly-educated members of society, or possessors of supreme power? I can go on and on with this debate, but the bottom line is when do individuals come to terms with the possibility they just might be wrong on something and it’s time to shut up and listen to someone perhaps more knowledgeable, regardless of age, academic credentials, race, ethnicity, gender, or power status in society? For more than thirty years I’ve routinely wondered when exactly my ideas have merit, or more precisely: when do I finally earn the respect of any human being for the simple courtesy of allowing me to calmly demonstrate that I know what the hell I’m talking about, be it about chemistry, physics, science education, football, or buying a lousy loaf of bread?
As embarrassed as I am to say it, I had a momentary urge to “slap the stupid” out of Juliette and tell her in front of anyone and everyone at Stop and Shop: You stupid kid! Is there any little warning light in your head telling you to shut up and listen to somebody more than twice your age, who actually grew up in an era BEFORE the metric system, much less computerized cash registers?! I don’t know about you, but I take great offense having to deal with people less knowledgeable than me who are UNWILLING to defer to my level of knowledge, and that’s pretty sad considering we’re talking about a trivial 24-ounce package of bread. This is hardly deciphering the New England Patriots no-huddle offense or quantum mechanics.
This is supposed to be America’s future, folks — the next generation of citizens for a rapidly changing information age, or what former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney calls a “Smart Phone Society.” If Juliette is an example of Romney’s “Smart Phone Society”, I hope Juliette’s smart phone can do the mother load of Juliette’s thinking, because I’m skeptical that she or many of her peers can think independently of automated machines. If you think I’m getting ahead of myself, keep in mind that young people like Juliette will be the continuous faces shown during the next fourteen months leading up to the 2012 presidential election as our economy remains mired in double-digit unemployment rates for most segments of America. Imagine the possible (I’m too cynical about our government and the US Congress to say words like “eventual”) passing of a Jobs Bill and employers pointing to people like Juliette as a primary reason why unemployment still cannot be reduced, claiming “you can’t hire dummies who can’t work with the most basic of knowledge.”
Now, people like Juliette are hardly unique. We’ve all encountered our share of cashiers and store clerks who can’t count change or perform the most basic of math operations without profound difficulty, and I probably wouldn’t even dwell on it so much if I hadn’t recently seen an HBO special showing “The best of ‘Hard Knocks’”, a compilation of ten years of candid camera moments from NFL training camps. If you haven’t seen this “Hard Knocks” retrospective, there’s one scene from the New York Jets training camp last summer where one assistant coach offers another a question (I’m paraphrasing it) from the Jeff Foxworthy show “Are you smarter than a fifth grader?” -- [A child] is holding two yard sticks and a 12-inch ruler. How many feet does that equal?
Needless to say, the second Jets assistant coach could not correctly answer the question, that the child is holding seven feet of measuring sticks. Why? Because he neither understood how many feet were in a yard nor how many inches were in a foot, and football is supposedly a game of inches, feet and yards! This is considered entertainment by HBO. I consider it embarrassing that my favorite NFL team still employs an assistant coach who can’t do fifth grade math.
We can test children and young adults until the cows come home in our schools and colleges and the simple truth is that those tests will never tell us whether children or young adults genuinely learned anything or understand what educational administrators and political leaders expect these citizens to know. Chances are this Jets assistant coach scored sufficiently enough on standardized tests to get through our educational systems and find employment in the NFL. Chances are Juliette scored just as sufficiently on whatever tests she had to take during her formal education and now she works for a moderately large grocery chain like Stop and Shop. Yet neither comprehend fundamental math knowledge our nation arbitrarily considers a benchmark for being a literate citizen, and that’s rather disturbing.
So what’s the take-home lesson or punch-line to this story? In a nation still muddling through a major recession, price inflation, stagnant wages, and double-digit unemployment for people lacking at least a bachelors degree, we have politicians and political pundits all screaming about job creation, but where’s the guarantee that all these new jobs can be filled by knowledgeable and capable people? If a better-paying opportunity becomes available for people like Juliette, will they really be qualified for these opportunities? If the New York Jets suddenly fire this one assistant coach and he needs to find new employment outside of football, will there be enough jobs he’s qualified for, or will he be limited by his inability to comprehend elementary school-level math? Worse, how do we know that one day we won’t turn on the six-o’clock news one evening and hear that Juliette didn’t poison her child because she didn’t know how to properly measure the correct dosage of medicine prescribed by a pediatrician? Don’t call me an alarmist, because we’ve all heard of at least one story over the past decade or two where parents improperly administered medication to a child because they either couldn’t read the directions on the package or measure out the medicine.
Everyone makes mistakes, just as everyone is capable of having a brain freeze. Even I’ve made calculation mistakes over the years, and the mistakes have become more frequent as I’ve gotten older. But I take my mistakes to heart; I take my mistakes seriously. That’s because I take knowledge seriously. Unfortunately, the same cannot be said for many citizens of Governor Romney’s “Smart Phone Society.” How many times have we heard young people (or not so young people) say there’s no need to remember certain things, because they can look it up on a computer?
What if a computer’s unavailable, like many were during Hurricane Irene, because tens of thousands of citizens were without electricity? What do you do then? Stop taking or administering medication on account of darkness? Declare a moratorium on measuring? That may be acceptable when it comes to portion control of your favorite comfort food during a blackout, but not when it comes to medication or something of equal importance.
I know... It was just a loaf of bread, but the loaf of bread is merely an example of an underlying problem with our educational system, especially when our educational system keeps emphasizing literacy and standardized testing of the basics, including mathematics. The underlying problem, folks, is that our educational system continues to fail at inspiring educators, administrators and learners to give a damn about knowledge in general. If it ain’t on the state or national test, it don’t matter. I actually wrote about this academic philosophy expressed by a veteran high school social studies teacher of the New York City public school system in my 2001 book Teacher training: A reference handbook. If there’s not high-stakes test or grade attached to information it’s simply white noise, as disposable a commodity as the six-pack of paper towels we all likely have on our typical grocery shopping lists. We teach knowledge and we test knowledge, but we really don’t care much about knowledge, simply because we don’t fully understand what knowledge is in the first place.
In my new book, Philosophy of “Packer” pedagogy I present a vision of what a critically-thinking and problem-solving literate society can be in terms of Vince Lombardi’s four core principals of teaching and learning. Lombardi’s fourth principal was “winning isn’t a sometimes thing, it’s an all the time thing.” I upgraded principal this to state: thinking and the effort to learn is (sic: are) not a sometimes thing, it’s an all the time thing. In other words, using your brain shouldn’t be an occasional luxury; it should be a daily endeavor. But we don’t have a dominant culture or society that advocates this principal beyond artificial academic assessment? How many times have we heard parents encourage or demand their children to “get good grades” as the daily objective of school. Just once, couldn’t parents encourage or demand their children demonstrate evidence of thinking, or even offer the advice don’t do anything stupid today?
As a parting thought, many of us have heard the saying “don’t argue with an idiot; no one will recognize the difference.” There’s considerable merit to that saying. Unfortunately, as you and I go through our daily lives, the sad truth is that the idiots in society tend to own the megaphones and airwaves, and we’re inundated with their oppressive droning. Ask yourself when’s the last time you were able to listen to a calm voice of reason that didn’t exist solely inside your head? Maybe it’s time we all got a little pissed off, mouthed off and slapped the stupid out of some folks. Who knows? We’ve may stun these nitwits into the silence we crave.
Reminder — Don’t forget my new Book! Don’t buy it because I’m “right” -- Buy it because I have something worthwhile to say and think about.
Philosophy of “Packer” Pedagogy:
Vince Lombardi, critical thinking and problem-based learning
http://www.lulu.com/spotlight/DavePushkin_PackerPedagogy
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)